Tvad
I was not being tongue in cheek.
Bob P
I think both of those statements can be true.
To my ears (as a digital "disser") CDs
1) accentuate frequencies - or add information? - that I find fatiguing.
But at the same time, digital often has
2) an absence of certain spatial cues, harmonic overtones, richness and depth.
In the case of a CD archived on a tape, I see no reason why the tape can't improve on point 1) and perhaps sound better.
Obviously, it can't create the missing info from point 2.
One audio writer, years ago, described the low noise of CDs as a silence of absence, not a silence of presence.
Nonetheless, perhaps the noise of analogue is in some way creates a better illusion of that, even with the information that was "missing" from the CD.