Check other reviews on ART9, and I think you'll see you cannot go wrong. That said, maybe others like Shelter would be different, and maybe even better in your system... but you can't go wrong with the ART9. IMO, it's a good high-end value.
I think your Allnic Phono Preamp would mate very well with it, and should sound great! It has 62db of gain, or 66db, either of which should be excellent.