I doubt gain differences are the problem. While muted, the difference in the two pre's gain capabilities shouldn't matter.
If the noise level isn't at or near zero when the pre is muted, then it sounds like it could be an impedance mismatch...
The tubes would seem pretty unlikely. When they go south, you will definitely know something is wrong.
If the noise level isn't at or near zero when the pre is muted, then it sounds like it could be an impedance mismatch...
The tubes would seem pretty unlikely. When they go south, you will definitely know something is wrong.