I would say that the one advantage to following the ASR sheep is that the units recommended by ASR can be resold very quickly and without taking as much of a haircut in the process.
I was revamping a system last year and the first two units that sold "measured very well". Those were the units I liked the least and thought would take the longest to sell.
For my next test I am going to try the GD Audio R-27 HE as a preamp/DAC combo. It fit my needs for where it was going and the sources that would be connected. Also, their latest DAC did very well in Stereophile which does not usually lavish praise on units in that price point.