I am only digital but we build our own components. The phono stage ($15,000) beats the crap out of any digital we have built or heard period. Not even close but our digital ($10,000) beats the crap out of most analog systems. So IMO in comes down to mostly the components. While different recordings have an impact, some of the poorest analog recording sound better than the best digital recordings with our components.
Happy Listening.
Happy Listening.