Am I Bad Listener?


Let me say from the outset that I love audio gear and I love the sound of mid-high end audio. But here's the thing ...

The only part of a system that I can hear a real difference in is speakers. In my system over the past few months I have tested three different amps (a 30W tube, a 150W SS integrated and a 200W SS amp plus a bi-amp configuration), a tube preamp, no preamp (direct to amp via DAC with volume control) and most recently a bunch of different speaker wires (my original Audience Maestros, a DIY Home Depot 10 gauge concoction, Anticables and two other sets of very expensive wires borrowed from a local dealer - some bi-wired & some single with jumpers). Oh, and a series of different IC's.

With the possible exception of the insertion of the tube preamp, I can't really tell much of a difference regardless of what I do. I have had similar experiences at dealers. But switching back and forth between different speakers I can hear huge differences.

I think my system sounds really good but is modest by comparison to many on A'gon - Olive Musica, Benchmark DAC, Minimax Preamp, Meridian G57 amp (sometimes switched for a Classe or Prima Luna) - so maybe that's it. In a modest system the effect of switching components or wires just won't yield huge sound changes. Or maybe I just don't hear in a very detailed manner.

I spend a fair amount of time reading posts here and people claim to have genuine sonic revelations by switching an interconnect or a tube or piece of speaker wire. I love buying the new stuff and giving it a try but I just don't seem to ever hear a sonic revelation and end up re-selling it.

Does anyone share my experience or is there something this sad, pathetic audiophile is missing?
Ag insider logo xs@2xitball

Showing 1 response by goatwuss

ITball,

You are right on for the most part. Speakers, and their interaction with the acoustic environment (room) accounts for 95% of the sound you hear, good or bad, assuming that the rest of the components are at least mid-level quality.

Tubes vs. Tranistors is another thing that you will hear, though this might require a bit of practice and a revealing system. A 40W push-pull EL34 amp like a Jolida will sound pretty different than a Class A Krell or something. With a well setup system, this is something that everyone should be able to hear. Not to say that all tube amps/transistor amps sound different, but some topologies (like the above) will.

Tied with that, changes in source are pretty audible, especially with analog. Listen to a Rega table with a cheap cartridge, and then a big VPI table with an expensive cartridge. You will hear some major differences here.

Digital sources are mixed bag, and changes are often quite a bit more subtle. Like one of the above posters said, a higher-end digital source can be the difference between being able to easily follow a bassline, or having it kind of getting lost in the mix. It won't be a major "this whole stereo sounds like crap" thing with a cheaper digital player, unless the CDP is really bad. (1989 Circuit City Sony or something)

Like you, I don't hear notable differences between cables, tubes, most tweaks, and SS amps.