Alternatives Software for iTunes on Mac


Been an iTunes user since its inception and quite satisfied with it with its overall sound quality in my system. Recently I have encountered some significant problems and have decided to look for an alternative to it. Have a large collection of music on a separate external hard drive in AIFF files, 2500 CDs or albums. Currently uses Apple airport express to wireless play music from my computer through a Rotes Integrated Amp and Monitor Audio Gold 100 speakers.  I am looking for a high quality software to replace iTunes. I must to able to easy transfer existing files to the new software. Any suggestion would be appreciated.
joscow
I use Audirvana Plus, works very well for me. I have no plans to change anything in this system: https://systems.audiogon.com/systems/7324
Another vote Audirvana. I’m not aware of better audio playback software for Mac. It can also stream Tidal from within the app and you can remote control it with your phone.
MacX MediaTrans

  • Back up your photos
  • Manage your entire music library
  • Transfer videos to and from your phone to other devices
  • Encrypt files
  • Manage voice and create customized ringtone as well
  • Organize your books
  • Use your phone as a flash drive

@joscow  What do you mean by "high quality"?  When you send music over wireless you really send data.  No matter what program you use it is still the same data (no timing involved), unless program modifies it somehow (like upsampling), making data not "bit perfect".  Make sure to set playback volume at max.  Playback program can affect quality when it can affect timing (jitter) of the D/A conversion.  It can happen when you output data with S/Pdif cable.  

I also use Itunes with Airport Express.  The only complain I have is clumsy interface.  I created "Smart Playlists" for each genre (for instance: "match music for the following rule: Genre is Classical") and select playlists.  It places thumbnails for each record - about 21 on each page. Much easier to find each record.
@joscow, What problem are you having with iTunes? Maybe it can be resolved. Like you I have been using iTunes for a long time. I still use it to wirelessly stream my AIFF ripped CDs to an Airport Express or Apple TV and have not encountered any problems.
I forgot to mention dropouts.  I had dropouts because at lower band 2.4GHz there are only 3 independent channels (since each of 12 channels is almost 4 channels wide).  I bought dual band router, switched to 5GHz and problem is gone.  5GHz has more channels and poorly penetrates walls making it difficult for outside signals to enter home.
ijgerens- for 6 weeks now,Having a problem with intermittent dropouts, hanging, and complete freezing resulting iTunes quitting. Sent reports to Apple. They elevated to engineering 3 days ago but have heard nothing from them regarding solving the problem. Now, it cannot get it to accept the current library. It has an old library that doesn't contain some of my most recent downloads and purchases. your thoughts
@joscow  Sorry to hear that.  I have I tunes Version 12.9.5.5 running on late 2014 MacMini with Mojave Version 10.14.6 and have zero problems.  I changed library, but it was long time ago.  There is Itunes media location (Preferences => Advanced) and Library name (Preferences => General).  All my files are under folder Itunes/Itunes Music.  I have marked (Preferences => Advanced)  "Keep Itunes Media Folder Organized" and "copy Files to Itunes Media folder when adding to Library".  When I point to any folder containing music and select File - Add to Library it adds listing to named Library and copies files to "Itunes media location".  You can start new Library with new name and media location and then add any file you want.  

I had dropouts with 2.4GHz but never hanging.  How much memory you have.  Exit programs you don't need.  I hope it will help.
I went thru many versions of OS and few Macs and never had problem with Itunes.
Another vote for Audirvana, it works flawlessly with MacOS, it is really user friendly and it allows to use iTunes Library together with any other that you want create. 
joscow The dropouts may be related to your WiFi. If you are on 2.4 GHz band try to change to a different channel or if you have a dual band router, try 5 GHz.

The freezes and hangups are a different matter. Perhaps you need to reinstall iTunes, or perhaps your iTunes library is corrupted. What version of iTunes are you using and what Mac OS and what are your computer specs. 

I am currently using a 2014 Mac Mini as a music server running Mojave Version 10.14.4 and iTunes Version 12.9.4.94 and have had no problems. For the last 9 years I have had several different Macs running different Mac OS versions and iTunes versions and never had a dropout, hangup or freeze. 
I love Audirvana - and it DOES sound better than iTunes.  But you must own all of the music in your library it it will not play in Audirvana.  This is a problem for me because I pay for Apple Music $15/mo and just add all kinds of whatever I want to my library, but then I can't remember if I "bought it" or not and my library becomes extremely frustrating to navigate, which is a big turn off to me.  So, if I'm in the mood to listen to older music that I know I own, its Audirvana and a joint.  If I'm working and streaming and just background music, its ITunes.  If I whip out the bong then you know I just warmed up my tube pre and am about to spin some vinyl!  
Audirvana has sounded superior to iTunes for years, especially when it started reading the music instead of having iTunes do it. ITunes for the car and maybe during a flight is ok. Try doing anything hires/dsd/mqa thru iTunes, you can’t. 
‘I got rid of audirvana a couple years ago and went with Roon, far superior in the user interface and how it adds tidal title to your library. The sq of Roon was better than audirvana when I switched but I have heard rumors that the new release of audirvana might sound better than Roon. 
Also, if you want quality playback, don’t use an airport express, too many restrictions.
I use JRiver Media Center.  Great playback quality via USB to a DAC, links to other DLNA based services, plays just about any format you can think of.  Relatively inexpensive licence.  JRemote can be used to drive it all from iPad or iPhone.  My Mac mini uses a wired connection which is rock solid.
Forgot to mention, Audirvana Plus works very well with Tidal. Tidal is actually integrated into the Audirvana control screen. No plans to change here, very happy with what I have.
We tried Audirvana a while ago and after considerable listening on my 3 systems and my wife's system, we could not tell any significant difference with iTunes. This was only with our AIFF ripped CDs streamed wirelessly. We do not use any internet music services, so I cannot comment on them. 
Thanks to all of you for your comments and/or suggestions. Still have an excellent ear for good sounding music and will now evaluate your suggestions. Have been extremely happy with iTunes in my system where most of the music is AIFF topped CDs but the problems of the last six weeks have caused me to look for an alternative. I will certainly evaluate Audirvana after receiving so many recommendations of it. Thanks again.
Right on!  And you are using a DAC right?  I have a Dragon Fly Red and it makes a huge difference too!
another vote here for Jrivers media center..  Very configurable and able to handle large Library sizes with ease..