AudiogoN
Search Buy Sell Learn MyPage
 Learn > Reviews > Digital > 1234500400  Start New Thread | Log In
  Review: Sony SCD-XA5400ES CD Player
I love natural recordings that capture the full acoustic envelope of the performances. The Shostakovich Sonatas performed by Ax and YYMa comes to mind...the Sony portrays the entire event in such an unforced and natural manner that it triggers ones acoustic memory into believing it is real. A player that offers no tone color or openness would be my worst nightmare. I replaced my BAT VK D5 24 bit CDP and was amazed at how much resolution and color was lost on the older design. The Sony re-creates the space, music and acoustic tones with overtones so completely that you start to smile and realize that you have been given a great gift...a peak into the performance as it occured at the recording session. My opinion of the Sony applies as much for the redbook section as it does for the SACD section. This player will become a classic product for digital playback....much better it does not get! It's a keeper at any price,,,for $1500 USD it is a freakin steal. This is Sony's best effort to date and manages to break new ground in the digital domain:)

Associated gear
Wilson Sophia speakers
Krell 400xi amp
Harmonic Tech Cables
MIT Oracle AC 2 power cord

Similar products
Sony SCD-1
Sony SCD-XA9000ES
Sony SCD-XA777ES
Levinson 39, 390S, 360S
Wadia 851
Krell SACD Standard
MF A5
BAT VK D524bit
ARC CD 3

by Dave_b on 02-12-09 
  Follow ups
Click title to read one, or click date to read all below it.

02-13-09   Interesting, would you rate it significantly better tha ...   Steelhead

02-13-09   Interested in knowing why you only compared it's cd sec ...   Schipo

02-13-09   Steelhead, the sony scd-xa5400es was just another exper ...   Dave_b

02-13-09   Details, details, details. are you using hdmi outputs ...   Buconero117

02-13-09   Rca sounds best, compared to the balanced outputs...don ...   Dave_b

02-17-09   As the player has broken in it has really blossomed; s ...   Dave_b

02-23-09   The xa5400es is superior to the oppo 980h for multi-cha ...   Disbeliever

02-23-09   Disbeliever, i agree the sony takes a long time to sett ...   Dave_b

02-27-09   Dave, i have been using a sony scd-xa777es for sever ...   Bobup1998

02-27-09   Cleaner sounding with more acoustic and spatial informa ...   Dave_b

02-27-09   Stop the presses....i just hooked up a pair of mit magn ...   Dave_b

02-27-09   Has anyone heard the 5400 pitted against the cambridge ...   Twoleftears

02-27-09   My brother had one from audio advisor and returned it.. ...   Dave_b

02-28-09   Update on xa5400es! breakin is quite extensive with th ...   Dave_b

03-09-09   The xa5400es is excellent with both stereo & multi-chan ...   Disbeliever

03-09-09   It's tough giving up on an old friend:o)   Dave_b

03-09-09   Dave, please try to gracefully accept that others may p ...   Tvad

03-10-09   Sorry, the old friend comment was meant sincerely. i l ...   Dave_b

03-10-09   Hi dave, have you compared the sony to the oppo ...   Wavetrader

03-10-09   The xa5400 is world class good, as in you can't get muc ...   Dave_b

03-10-09   Sorry, dave. i misinterpreted your comment as a dig.   Tvad

03-11-09   No problem, i have alot of gear i loved and let go over ...   Dave_b

03-20-09   Hey dave, my krell sacd standard version 3 has been 10 ...   Joeyboynj

03-20-09   That's great news joeyboynj...enjot it in good health:o ...   Dave_b

03-23-09   I've had one of these since november and i agree it is ...   Rwetmore

03-23-09   Whilst i agree the xa5400es is very good its real fort ...   Disbeliever

03-23-09   You must keep in mind that i am using the xa5400es in a ...   Dave_b

03-30-09   This player is on my short list, along with the arcam c ...   Prepress

03-30-09   The player is very rewarding and i purchased on faith d ...   Dave_b

04-12-09   I have had the sony and a marantz sa-11s2 in my system ...   Billmcd

04-14-09   It may not be perfect, but it is a stone cold high end ...   Dave_b

04-14-09   Humm....i had a sony xa-777es a few years back, and i l ...   Sogood51

04-16-09   Kal rubinson, in the new issue of stereophile, kicks th ...   Dave_b

04-19-09   The sony xa5400es is an excellent player for both rb cd ...   Disbeliever

04-24-09   I just bought one on the 'gone at a great price; $300-$ ...   Eddaytona

04-24-09   The sony needs as good a power cord and ic as you can a ...   Dave_b

04-24-09   tube output devices can euphonize th ...   Tvad

04-25-09   Tvad makes good points and i can only speak from my own ...   Dave_b

04-25-09   The power cord supplied with the uk xa5400es is a total ...   Disbeliever

04-27-09   Compared to some of my $15k products the sony cord 'ain ...   Dave_b

04-27-09   Thanks for your review. you indicated that you have co ...   Abind

04-28-09   The sony has absolutely zero digital nasties and presen ...   Dave_b

04-28-09   I was going to buy the xa5400es, then i saw the negativ ...   Aarif

04-28-09   Not sure what aarif is smokin, but good luck with the n ...   Dave_b

04-28-09   Is your comment meant to be amusing aarif? if it is, i ...   Roxy54

04-30-09   Now using a transparent powerlink mm and mit v1.2 proli ...   Dave_b

04-30-09   Roxy54 writes: is your comment me ...   Metralla

04-30-09   Ah, the ongoing evolution of the species made evident b ...   Dave_b

04-30-09   There's nothing more to say, you just said it dave. tha ...   Roxy54

04-30-09   At least you know people are reading your review. i am ...   Metralla

05-01-09   Metralla rising...and with candor! good to know there ...   Dave_b

05-03-09   Aarif's comment was mildly funny. what really put me o ...   Plinko

05-03-09   Anyone compare this player to separates or sota one box ...   Sgr

05-03-09   No meridian player will play sacd. fwiw. kal   Kr4

05-03-09   Well how does fare against other top redbook cd players ...   Sgr

05-03-09   May stereophile 'music in the round' kal rubinson's par ...   Disbeliever

05-03-09   This player is not discontinued as far as i know...it j ...   Dave_b

05-03-09   Apparently, it is nearly impossible to find in europe a ...   Kr4

05-03-09   Kal is correct...i didn't say it would be easy to find ...   Dave_b

05-03-09   Oh yeah, almost forgot to mention, i owned a meridian g ...   Dave_b

07-01-09   Possible to find in germany from hifiberlinshop.de for ...   Cyrilmartin

07-01-09   Hi cyrilmartin! after a few months (depending on your ...   Dave_b

07-02-09   Thank you- i have another source and the problem isn't ...   Cyrilmartin

Review: Sony SCD-XA5400ES CD Player
How long have you had the player? Breakin time is crucial for the Sony till it smooths out. With my PC it has the cleanest, purest most extended high frequency range of any player I've owned. I still think you have a problem elsewhere in the chain that the XA5400ES is showing up or passing along:O)
Dave_b 07-04-09


07-07-09   Dave, this only happens on cd- sacd is clean... digital ...   Cyrilmartin

07-07-09   I saw a 5400 on the workbench at allen wright's (vacuum ...   Metralla

07-07-09   Cyrilmartin, i have maggie 3.6r's now so i think 40khz ...   Dave_b

07-08-09   Alright, i did some digging and have a bit of informati ...   Cyrilmartin

07-09-09   Update 2: i obtained the design white paper from sony r ...   Cyrilmartin

07-09-09   Wow, good stuff cyrilmartin...thanks:o)   Dave_b

07-13-09   Cyrilmartin which is a better cd player than the xa540 ...   Disbeliever

07-13-09   Disbeliever writes: i will be ver ...   Metralla

07-22-09   Well metralla...how does the mod sound on the xa5400es?   Dave_b

07-24-09   Dear cyrilmartin, thank you very much for your research ...   Tino_miky

07-24-09   Tino, yes, i have compared the sony with the mag ...   Cyrilmartin

07-24-09   I have to say guys, that this is a case of a little und ...   Dave_b

07-24-09   ...the sony has the most natural and ...   Tvad

07-24-09   I forgot to mention that i am around acoustic instrumen ...   Dave_b

07-25-09   So much for the case of "little understanding"... a ta ...   Cyrilmartin

07-25-09   Wow, i am amazed again! i owned a meridian g08...sucke ...   Dave_b

08-02-09   New cable find for the frugal and acousticaly astute. ...   Dave_b

08-02-09   i dare you to try them. dave_b ( ...   Tvad

08-02-09   I looked at the monster sp1000, but decided not to purc ...   Tvad

08-02-09   No not at all tvad. in fact i am getting quite fed up ...   Dave_b

08-02-09   5 feet is too long for my installation, believe it or n ...   Tvad

08-02-09   I'll check it out...the sp1000 comes with pro velcro st ...   Dave_b

08-02-09   Pro velcro... now there's something... :)   Tvad

08-02-09   Proline velcro...says so right on the strap so it must ...   Dave_b

08-06-09   Hi dave! do you think the rca version of the mon ...   Tube_guy

08-06-09   I'm not sure an rca version exists for the sp1000 cable ...   Dave_b

08-09-09   I was recently at vacuum state electronics in switzerla ...   Metralla

08-10-09   The setup at vse looks a little disturbing to me:o t ...   Dave_b

08-11-09   Dave_b, the speakers are very close to the side ...   Metralla

11-14-09   Hi everyone. this sony seems a very capable player. my ...   Crimhead

11-14-09   Crimhead, yes, yes, yes, yes and most definately yes! ...   Dave_b

11-16-09   Is there any review available on this cdp? i've not fou ...   Crimhead

11-16-09   Techradar.com has a full review and kal rubinson mentio ...   Dave_b

11-16-09   Techradar realy praises this cdp, but comparison is mad ...   Crimhead

11-16-09   Crimhead, i owned levinson no. 39, 390s, 360s&37combo, ...   Dave_b

11-21-09   No digital input? i reviewed the official specs and di ...   Artmaltman

11-21-09   It has a digital output but not for sacd, of course.br ...   Kr4

11-24-09   Kal, what do you think of the sony after having spent s ...   Dave_b

11-25-09   How would you feel about audio (german mag) rated this ...   Crimhead

11-25-09   They are all great players. the sony is certainly the ...   Dave_b

12-15-09   i just ordered one of these to hold me over till i ge ...   Budt

12-16-09   Hey budt, i'd be interested in your impressions after y ...   Dave_b

12-19-09   Budt, please post your impressions. i am on the ...   Michael10

12-23-09   Xa5400es is an excellent player best value on the marke ...   Disbeliever

12-23-09   Disbeliever is right...no problems with sibilance or hi ...   Dave_b

12-23-09   well, just a quick note.i connected this player in my ...   Budt

12-23-09   Budt, several hundred hours of play time will bring a f ...   Dave_b

12-24-09   I was thinking of upgrading to a raysonic to serve as t ...   Mst

12-26-09   Like 5 seconds unless switching from rb to sacd which i ...   Dave_b

12-29-09   What about the headphone output on this thing? how good ...   Branislav

12-30-09   I don't have great phones but it sounds sweet to me!   Dave_b

01-01-10   Dave_b! very interesting post about the 5400 sony,you m ...   Puiutu62

01-01-10   No and no, but the accuphase stuff is known for musical ...   Dave_b

01-02-10   Thanks dave_b for your answer! i use now a cd player fr ...   Puiutu62

01-06-10   Just recieved a pair of mit m1.3 prolines from joe abra ...   Dave_b

01-15-10   I bought one through crutchfield and i am on the fence. ...   Clayx

01-16-10   Clayx, have you put 400+hrs on the unit yet? the sony ...   Dave_b

01-16-10   Dave, thanks for your input. i do not have 400 hours o ...   Clayx

02-09-10   Dave great review,i'm searching for a cdp, and saw this ...   Karmatogdral

02-09-10   The sony has excellent bass response and dynamic contra ...   Dave_b

02-15-10   Hi, i also bought this sony, which was my first ...   Sequence56

03-02-10   I am using the sony with xlo signature 3 interconnects, ...   Peterng123

03-10-10   ...i was wondering if the tray design and mechanism lik ...   Mamifero76

03-12-10   I haven't heard this particular sony, but i have two th ...   Dbdeeb

03-12-10   The 5400 reads cds and sacds very quickly. i have not m ...   Metralla

03-13-10   Has any one compared the rb portion to well reviewed da ...   Twinda1

04-16-10   one way to make the very good sony scd-xa5400es cd pl ...   Audioman58

04-16-10   I have compared the sony 5400 forget the benchmark it i ...   Audioman58

04-23-10   Check out the new mapleshade clearview excalibur plus x ...   Dave_b

04-23-10   04-16-10: audioman58 writes: dan says ...   Metralla

04-23-10   The sony is such a great platform to build on the world ...   Audioman58

04-26-10   I have also upgraded the xa5400es and you can find deta ...   Tino_miky

05-01-10   How to make the sony 5400 much better , start with t ...   Audioman58

05-01-10   Thank you tino_miky. fascinating. regards,   Metralla

05-09-10   How can adding distortion (tubes) improve the sound ?   Disbeliever

05-10-10   Many websites mention sony's str-da5500es as the ideal ...   Cypriot

05-11-10   Yes the sony xa5400es must be used with a matching rece ...   Disbeliever

05-16-10   Disbeliever, thanks for the input. any other opinions ...   Cypriot

05-17-10   Dave b is not correct especially if you are into mch sa ...   Disbeliever

06-06-10   to disbeliever vaccum tubes are not just about distor ...   Audioman58

06-08-10   Vacuum tubes have far more distortion than transistors ...   Disbeliever

06-08-10   He's not disbeliever for nothing.   Tvad

06-10-10   Regardless of the fact vaccum tubes wear out what they ...   Audioman58

06-29-10   After hearding the terra firma mod of the sony xa5400 i ...   Audioman58

07-06-10   I sent my player to dan wright today. for $2000 dollar ...   Dave_b

07-20-10   Dave----your review of sony xa5400es convinced me to bu ...   Gregfey

07-29-10   Nice system gregfey! i'll be sure to post my review af ...   Dave_b

08-30-10   Tube designs have their followers, nostalgia and a beli ...   Disbeliever

09-02-10   Who are you talking too disbeliever? this post is in r ...   Dave_b

09-05-10   Good for you   Disbeliever

09-05-10   I go to live classical concerts and jazz clubs, and gue ...   Jwm

09-17-10   I just put my new shunyata python cx pc out of the box ...   Sequence56

09-17-10   so i wonder if the modwright sho ...   Tvad

09-18-10   Tvad, thanks again, that's exactly what i want to hear! ...   Sequence56

09-18-10   Sequence56, you're welcome. good luck.   Tvad

09-29-10   Disbeliever--as dan wright of modwright accurately stat ...   Timo

10-02-10   Absolutely timo...dan uses each technology to it's best ...   Dave_b

11-24-10   Pitch noise !!!!! i was enjoying the 5400es thi ...   Tube_guy

12-01-10   No, i have not.   Dave_b

12-12-10   Its impossible to find this player in the uk - i'm gett ...   Mohit25

12-12-10   Contact dan at modwright..shouldn't be a problem:o)   Dave_b

12-12-10   Thanks, dave. i fear that usd 1995 for modifications ma ...   Mohit25

12-12-10   These days, for a hundred bucks you might get some good ...   Roxy54

12-12-10   Thanks for the snide remark - i hope it made you feel b ...   Mohit25

12-13-10   I understand completely...i meant to imply that dan cou ...   Dave_b

12-13-10   Thanks, dave. thats a great idea !   Mohit25

12-16-10   Mohit25. i have the 5400 with modwright mods - absolute ...   Peteferg

12-20-10   Thanks, peter for taking the time to respond. it sounds ...   Mohit25

12-20-10   I have an integrated, simaudio i7 and speakers dynaudio ...   Mld1905

12-21-10   Mohit25, i just saw your response to my post. i was ...   Roxy54

12-26-10   Thank you for that clarification, roxy. i was not looki ...   Mohit25

01-14-11   Hello all! first time posting here. i just bough ...   Audiolover718

02-01-11   The xa5400es sounds best via hdmi into the sony da6400e ...   Disbeliever

02-01-11   I have the modright modded cd player that you are knock ...   Jwm

02-02-11   Good for you,   Disbeliever

03-18-11   Hi dave anticipating your impressions of the mod ...   Tubegroover

03-20-11   I wrote a lengthy response tubegroover, but it wasn't p ...   Dave_b

03-20-11   After all that, you dumped it dave? you can really turn ...   Roxy54

03-21-11   I moved out of my previous environment too much smaller ...   Dave_b

03-21-11   Thanks dave for your clarification. i am really interes ...   Tubegroover

05-18-11   Hi, thanks you for all the informative discussi ...   Sacdlee

06-04-11   Fyi, i put together a very musicaly satisfying system ...   Dave_b

06-04-11   Hi dave, what pc's are you now using with each p ...   Tube_guy

06-04-11   I have an mit magnum ac2 on my nad c375bee, an audioque ...   Dave_b

06-07-11   Dave, thanks for the description of your new set ...   Tube_guy

06-07-11   I'm not sure really, as my time with the nad and the ya ...   Dave_b

08-18-11   I'm very happy with the meridian g08, but would like on ...   Jim_wojno

08-23-11   If you can afford the meridian you can afford the sony ...   Jwm

03-09-13   Perhaps one or two of you sony xa5400es users can help ...   Tbng

  Post your follow up
Subtitle (change if you like)
  


Your response (keep it on topic)
  


Username (email if non-member)
 
 

Password (for members only)
 
 

        

Please note: your submission will be held until moderator approval