Review: Shure M97xE Cartridge
MGM's Kama-Sutra recording of The Lovin' Spoonful's Greatest Hits sounds absolutely drone while the Rhino version of the same is clearly delightful. That is so true. I remember those original pressings from the '60s and they were gawdawful--noisy, compressed, practically unlistenable.
Thanks for another comprehensive review and what has served as a sanity check for me, because it corroborates what I've been experiencing. I have an M97xE on a Technics SL1210 M5G and it just keeps sounding better and better. It has far exceeded the resolution and musical satisfaction I expected of a cartridge at this price.
I started out in March with both an Ortofon OM 10 and the Shure. At first I liked the Ortofon better, but over time the Shure has emerged as the clear winner. It has a richness of presentation that belies its modest price.
I would describe a fully broken-in M97xE as neutral while avoiding any hint of sterility. It is also quick without being edgy. Spinning platters with this Shure evokes the strongest emotional reactions I've ever experienced when playing recorded music in my home.
I also like its sound better with the brush down in place, and in that configuration it'll play warped records that would toss most stylii right out of the groove. I sure hope Shure keeps this one in its lineup for some time to come.
Johnnyb53 06-19-07
Review: Shure M97xE Cartridge
"I started out in March with both an Ortofon OM 10 and the Shure. At first I liked the Ortofon better, but over time the Shure has emerged as the clear winner. It has a richness of presentation that belies its modest price." Ya know, JB...this is precisely how I feel! Even though my review of the Ortofon OM5E is dated recently here on Audiogon...I wrote most of it on EPINIONS about two years ago. This time around...my M97xE review is debuting on Audiogon and the EPINIONS version will just have to wait until they get a slot for the product. Fine...I don't mind that and I am really starting to LUV this site as finally...here is a home for those who can wax excitement about a low cost high-performing product without having to worry about dumb retaliatory remarks. I am most impressed with the intelligence level here and have learned plenty in the short time I've been here.
"I also like its sound better with the brush down in place, and in that configuration it'll play warped records that would toss most stylii right out of the groove. I sure hope Shure keeps this one in its lineup for some time to come." Yes, John...and you know what?? I remember actually witnessing the difference the stabilizer makes when I owned my Shure V-15 Type V back in 1982 and Shure sent me their ERA V Test Record. There was a band of sub audible frequencies that caused the cartridge to visibly and audibly warble without the Dynamic Stabilizer in place. When engaged...the warbling totally disappeared.
Now think about that...I realize that Shure was simulating warps with those deep bass frequencies but doesn't it stand to reason that the cartridge will also handle bass frequencies above the sub audible ones very well also...with the stabilizer in place?
JB...I don't think you have to worry about Shure discontinuing this cart any time soon. It's too popular right now! Another thing that I wish to say here right now is for the benefit of those who stumble upon this thread whether it be in the near future or further on. Both John and myself have found something very special with this Shure M97xE. There is something about this Type II cantilever that differs drastically from any other type or manufacture. IT JUST KEEPS GETTING BETTER WITH AGE! What is with this?
Yes my OM5e wa my #1 but now it s the M97xE and am afrad tt nthng else wil do!
Also...please note, folks that the cart is doing well in a top rated Technics 1205MG, a Pioneer PL-518 {which is their answer to the Technics}, and a Perpetuum Ebner PE 3048 {which is similar to the Dual 1228 and 1218}. Please note that the first two tables are DIRECT DRIVE units. So much for the theory some audiophles have abot DD types not being of "audophile quality".
Thanks, JB for yor most kind and wonderful remarks. You have great insight yourself and I believe many will benefit from it!
Petsound 06-19-07
Review: Shure M97xE Cartridge John...Sorry I screwed up your table model but my keyboard went wacky a bit. I meant to say Technics SL-1210 M5G. OK...Me and the darn keyboard got a bit senile for a moment! At any rate I apologize and I hope the people catch the drift. The M97xE is now my standard and I fear that any other cart just won't do!...Peter
Petsound 06-19-07
Review: Shure M97xE Cartridge Petsound - enjoyed your review very much. I'm a fan of over-achieving/under-rated stuff. Seems to me I have seen 2 very positive reviews of the M97xE here on Audiogon. I am definitely inclined to purchase one. Appears to be a great value. (I too have an SL1210 M5G, purhcased from KAB early this year).
Ghosthouse 06-20-07
Review: Shure M97xE Cartridge
"I too have an SL1210 M5G, purhcased from KAB early this year." Please note that the very reputable KAB features the M97xE in their top table. There is good reason for this as the co. realizes that no other cart keeps the stereo image in such great focus! Go for it! Thanks for your kind response to the review...Peter
Petsound 06-20-07
Review: Shure M97xE Cartridge Ed Kobesky's review of the Technics SL1200 mk2 also cites the Shure M97xE as an excellent match (http://forum.audiogon.com/cgi-bin/frr.pl?ranlg&1093010514&read&3&4&). I wonder if some of his caveats about the match diminished over time, given the way this cart just keeps sounding better and better?
Johnnyb53 06-20-07
Review: Shure M97xE Cartridge Just a little UPDATE:7/13/07:
I have transferred the M97xE back into the fabulous Pioneer PL-518 using the $12 Black Phanstiehl headshell. Perfect alignment was set precisely midway of the headshell slots while keeping the cartridge perfectly straight. I like the design of this low cost headshell as it is ever so slightly sloped and VTA is absolutely perfect in the Pio's medium mass "S" tonearm. The headshell has just enough mass to it to work perfectly with the Shure in the Pio tonearm.
I am currently working on a new special patchcord for the PL-518 and will give a full update when mission accomplished.
Petsound 07-13-07
Review: Shure M97xE Cartridge Mission accomplished! The new gold-plated RCA OFC patchord works great and all went well during install. The M97xE is wonderful in the Phanstiehl HS. The sound is glorious!...Peter
Petsound 08-05-07
Review: Shure M97xE Cartridge G'day all, I have three M97xE's on different turntables and completely agree with all the comments. Yes the dynamic stabiliser works extremely well and makes this cartridge compatible with just about any tonearm.
Re 'break in' I recently observed this for myself with one of my M97xE's and I thought I was imagining it! I wasn't. Yes my M97xE's just get better with time!
I find that optimal loading also makes a significant difference with the M97xE, especially in the upper treble. As I DIY my own phono preamps I resistively load my M97xE's at 62 k, in lieu of the 'usual' 47 k and I also keep the capacitive loading to the recommended Shure value. Regards, Fap.
Fap 09-16-08
Review: Shure M97xE Cartridge Thanks for your comment, Fap and sorry I'm a bit late with my response but I've been having too much fun lately mounting and listening to my M97xE and Omega in a brand new GLI Pro SL-2500 DD turntable.
First...the new table is a dream and of course it is a much lower cost version of the Technics SL-1210 M5G. The sound is teriffic with the M97xE. I use the TEC 760LC phono preamp which is very similar to the NAD PP-2. The TEC's input is rated at 47K ohms. I also used a cheaper Phantone preamp rated at 50K ohms and noticed a slight lift in the mids and treble frequencies but still prefer my Tec with its 47K ohms loading as the cart now has a completely neutral & quiet quality whilst attaining a very broad w/three-dimensional soundstaging. Wonderful depth with no hype!
I believe it really is a completely neutral well-balanced keeper and just might win the hearts of enough former V-15 III owners {like myserlf!} to help the cause! Oh...by the way..."SAVEVINYL" on Ebay has the proper audiophile headshell for the SL-2500 and other Technics types whereas the cartridge easily mounts and is midway straight when aligned with the Shure's included protractor...which I still feel is the best of any!
I'm gonna have a report on this site very soon about all this. See ya then!!
Petsound 01-24-11
|
|