AudiogoN
Search Buy Sell Learn MyPage
 Learn > Forums > Tech talk > 1096313346  Start New Thread | Log In | Bookmark This
  Fidelity
I am trying to learn to ask questions, so I am asking this.Do high fidelity and accuracy mean the same thing to you, and do how do they really rate in your overall enjoyment of music? To me fidelity used to mean real to life until I realized I didnt really know what that meant. I have not heard that many live instruments or live performers. Then, I do not really know what an engineer or artist intended a recording to sound like either. Most of the time I am pretty happy just to listen to a recording and take it as is. I like or I dont. But this question of fidelity puzzles me. If this is an ignorant question I dont mind saying there is a lot I dont know.
Timf  (System | Threads | Answers | This Thread)

09-27-04
  Responses (1-30 of 30)
Click title to read one, or click date to read all below it.

09-27-04   Tim, if you just know that "you like it or you don't&q ...   Reubent

09-27-04   It's not a stupid question. for it not to be an ignorant qu ...   Uppermidfi

09-27-04   It's actually an interesting philosophical question, though ...   Rcprince

09-27-04   Hi tim, i would generally agree with many points that uppre ...   Bright_star_audio

09-27-04   Uppermidfi, a lot of us "golden eared freaks" ca ...   Prpixel

09-27-04   Thank you. i appreciate your answers.reubent: i like your ad ...   Timf

09-27-04   Let me rephrase that... the holy grail of hi-fi is to recre ...   Prpixel

09-27-04   Hi tim, i'm sure many of us neurotic audiophiles here (myse ...   Bright_star_audio

09-27-04   Just to reiterate a stance that i've personally had for year ...   Exertfluffer

09-28-04   I am imagining how the words high fidelity were first used t ...   Viggen

09-28-04   I'll go with reubant to block, bob. he said it plain and si ...   Jax2

09-28-04   "the holy grail of hi-fi is to recreate the recording e ...   Satch

09-28-04   I agree with marco, if your enjoying the music and it sounds ...   Prpixel

09-28-04   Prpixel - let us all know if your ding-dong makes it to the ...   Jax2

09-28-04   a lot of good responses. supportive, i think, and i appreci ...   Timf

09-28-04   Timf, on your last point, i have not heard any system that c ...   Rcprince

09-28-04   Hi tim, the term "dynamics" refers to the differe ...   Bright_star_audio

09-28-04   Rcprince, i wanted to say i enjoyed your original post.i do ...   Timf

09-28-04   I just browsed through this thread again hoping to learn som ...   Viggen

09-28-04   "the original", viggen, was conceived, performed, ...   Jax2

09-28-04   Some thoughts webster's dictionary indicates that one of th ...   Johnrob

09-28-04   jax2, i like your analogy of the telephone game. i understa ...   Timf

09-28-04   Hi rcprince, you said: "maybe the wamm or the irs v in ...   Bright_star_audio

09-29-04   I'd hope that all of us, at one time or other, has had the e ...   Jax2

09-29-04   I think we can all agree on the semantics: "fidelity&qu ...   Gregm

09-29-04   why?!?! why would anyone need anything more than enjoyment ...   Jax2

09-29-04: Jax2
Needless to say, I'll take 'enjoyment' as my priority
every single time. That may in fact lead to someone else's resemblence
to accuracy, but it sure wasn't my motivating factor.

I felt the need to explain that further as I didn't turn any music on and am still stuck in my head.

I compared three preamps in one of my systems the other day. When I listened for very specific cues as to why each differed from the other, in order to 'analyze' each one more 'critically' I really had no sense of enjoyment of the music at all, nor any sense of how much I was enjoying the preamp under scrutiny. When I let go of all the analytical games was when my toe started tapping and my body started moving...I was becoming more physically and emotionally involved in the music, and loving every second of it. Going from one preamp to another in my system I found that one had me moving, while another, although remarkably airy and dimensional in this case, did not seem to have what it took to engage me nearly as much. I could easily become distracted and disengaged with the music. Perhaps that is what critics call a component that is too "analytical". Regardless, my preference was with the component that got me out of my head and bobbing to the music. I really don't think that "accuracy" necessarily was the primary virtue that leads to that. I'm not sure what is though, and I don't really feel the need to quantify it. If it's there, there's really no mistaking it. Yes, it can certainly be there in one's experience of a "low-fidelity" system too. I think one's expectations may be the enemy to contend with there.

Marco

Jax2  (Reviews | Threads | Answers | This Thread)


09-29-04   Honestly. i do enjoy my system, and enjoyment of music is th ...   Timf

09-29-04   My father learned how to cook from the old foggies soldiers ...   Viggen

10-02-04   And so you know, right? what comes closest to this? nothing ...   Timf


  Post your response
Subject


Your response

No html, but you may use markup tags


Username
Members only

Password