AudiogoN
Search Buy Sell Learn MyPage
 Learn > Forums > Best of > 931763845  Start New Thread | Log In | Bookmark This

  Tubes? Transistors? Which are better?
It's an audiophile debate: Which are better, tubes or transistors? I have a been a big fan of transistors for a long time, but recent auditions have turned me into a partial tube head. Which tube designs sound best? Do transistors sound better?
Uliver@nac.net  

07-12-99
  Responses (51-99 of 99)
Click title to read one, or click date to read all below it.

11-19-00   Well it's you for me and me for euphony. we're probably talk ...   Khrys

11-19-00   I guess i'm too "careful" to even try to answer su ...   Carl_eber

11-20-00   Khrys: i'm reasonably confident that semantic differences ar ...   Waldhorner@

11-20-00   Sedond: the concert hall, being the acoustical space within ...   Waldhorner@

11-20-00   Waldhorner, i agree w/ewe. my only point is that there isn' ...   Sedond

11-20-00   Y'all have gone way off the original subject of tube vs. tra ...   Bob_bundus

11-20-00   Hi bob good points. a poor recording will bring more attent ...   Tubegroover

11-20-00   Bob: meandering divergence from the matter-at-hand contribut ...   Waldhorner@

11-20-00   Sedond: glad we've found some agreement. but i've never cons ...   Waldhorner@

11-21-00   Wald - diverging is ok, i wasn't squaking 'bout that; just g ...   Bob_bundus

11-21-00   Hi bob, for tone controls, mark levinson's old company *cell ...   Sedond

11-21-00   Doug you just made me remember my yamaha dsp-1 signal proces ...   Tubegroover

11-21-00   Toobgroover - that dsp-1 was the 1st ambient-surround set-up ...   Sedond

11-22-00   Bob: it's interesting how respectable tone controls became w ...   Waldhorner@

11-22-00   Tubes vs solid state i think it's a horse apiece.both do ce ...   Brutus@

11-25-00   This thread was resurrected at an interesting time for me. ...   Garfish

11-26-00   Sedond, sorry it took so long to respond: i'm going digital. ...   Joe_coherent

12-03-00   Carl the only thing your cd 50 can wipe ip is the barf from ...   Leafs

12-03-00   I had a solid state int for 20 years.when it came time to up ...   Leafs

12-04-00   One of the reasons i bought my current amp was the fact that ...   Trelja

12-04-00   leafs, didn't you post the short review about rogue amp, o ...   Eldragon

12-04-00   Hey, leafs, i finally got to hear my brother-in-law's res-au ...   Sedond

12-06-00   Yes i did post on the rogue   Leafs

12-08-00   Another issue which is underplayed is maintenance. tube amp ...   Dustych

12-14-00   It's a matter of personal taste but that even order distorti ...   Gmkowal@

12-15-00   Tubes have so much more soul, right ...   Svhoffy@

12-15-00   After 3 weeks of listening to a sf power 2 (tubes), i switch ...   Garfish

01-03-01   interesting findings by craig! i recently replaced my linn ...   Eldragon

01-03-01   Good for ewe, eldragon! same experience i had replacing my ...   Sedond

01-03-01   Boy craig you sure are a tough nut to crack! what's it gone ...   Tubegroover

01-03-01   Hi will; first, i really enjoyed my time with the sf power ...   Garfish

01-04-01   Garfish, perhaps you should investigate different tube amps. ...   Trelja

01-04-01   Hi trelja; i appreciate and understand your advice and real ...   Garfish

01-04-01   I think there's an inneresting dichotomy here - w/tubed amps ...   Sedond

01-04-01   You know doug i think maybe it comes down more to taste and ...   Tubegroover

01-04-01   Tubegroover, ewe could be right - for *me*, while i *do* lov ...   Sedond

01-04-01   On this one, i keep coming back to moderate price tube pre-a ...   Garfish

01-05-01   Hey craig, why stop at vtl's mb450? why not the mb750's or ...   Sedond

01-05-01   Garfish, i am not sure what type of sound you are into, but ...   Trelja

01-05-01   Tubegroover, your excellent post is probably the best explan ...   Rcprince

01-06-01   Trelja; a lot of the music i listen to depends on good rhyt ...   Garfish

01-08-01   You are always on point garfish. i agree with everything yo ...   Trelja

04-03-02   All roads lead to rome... good gear is good gear, transistor ...   Tmcroy

07-13-02   The impression i'm getting is that the ss amps have great de ...   Redwoodgarden

07-17-02   Red: first try upgrading your internal speaker wiring & the ...   Bob_bundus

07-20-02   I find the highs made by ss repro to be a bit harsh on my ea ...   Thatch_ear

07-20-02: Kevziek
In my experience, solid state does not sound as musical as tubes. On a very basic level, tubes sound more like the instruments sound. SS is thinner, flatter, less fleshed out, less dimensional, less body, less harmonic structure.

I don't care anymore about damping factor, the tightest and most powerful bass, the last shred of detail, the lowest distortion, etc., ad nauseum. All I care about is what gives me the most pleasure and sounds more REAL. To be honest, I have found that tubes actually give the MOST detail; they are better able to sort out the instrumental lines than any solid state amp does. Yes, there might be some tiny detailing that is more evident on SS, but SS still does not keep the instrumental lines as separated and does not give you the organic "whole" of the entire musical ensemble. It's hard to explain, but when you hear the things tubes do so much better, you don't want to listen to SS anymore. I'm a musician, so my ear is quite atuned to knowing what sounds most like the musical experience, and tubes are that.

Kevziek  (Reviews | Threads | Answers | This Thread)


07-31-02   I am in total agreement with tubegroover and kevziek. tubes ...   Nismo


< Prev 1 | 2

  Post your response
Subject


Your response

No html, but you may use markup tags


Username
Members only

Password