AudiogoN
Search Buy Sell Learn MyPage
 Learn > Forums > Music > 1304264076  Start New Thread | Log In | Bookmark This

  Who was the best jazz guitarist ever?

Since all music is "subjective", I lay no claim to any objective truth to anything I write on this subject.

Johnny Smith was the first to make me aware of the guitar as a jazz instrument. Before him I considered it to be a country and western or blues instrument. "Moonlight in Vermont" is his most famous album, it contains some of the most beautiful versions of standards I've ever heard.

Kenny Burrell who was often featured with Jimmy Smith on organ was the next jazz guitarist I became aware of. While his work with Jimmy Smith was tops, "Midnight Blue" on Blue Note, is my favorite album.

Wes Montgomery came to my attention twice, that's because according to some; he was better and more inclusively "jazz", before he became famous. The "Wes Montgomery Trio" recorded in 1959 is one example of a recording made before he became famous. His "Round Midnight" had a deep soulful intensity that's hard to match; but jazz guitarist's also have bills to pay.

Grant Green is the best jazz guitarist ever, his prodigious output makes that statement. There are some who claim, that out of all of the versions of "Round Midnight", his is the best.

There are many guitarist's I like who may or may not fit the description of "jazz guitarist". I'll leave the strict definition of that to others. Al Di Meola, John McLaughlin, and Paco De Lucia are guitarists I like a lot whatever category they fit in.

Since I prefer the broad definition of "jazz" as opposed to the strict definition, if you think your favorite guitarist fits the description; so do I. Who are your favorite guitarists?
Orpheus10  (Threads | Answers | This Thread)

05-01-11
  Responses (1-72 of 72)
Click title to read one, or click date to read all below it.

05-01-11   My favorites include jim hall, john abercrombie, joe pass, d ...   Bdgregory

05-01-11: Ferrari
All those you named above were influenced by Charlie Christian and Djando Reinhardt. To throw a few more names into the mix would be Barney Kressel, Herb Ellis, Charlie Byrd and Joe Pass. All of them worth a serious mention, to discover their music. In my view there is not one greatest ever, each brought their own style and flair to not only the music but the guitar as well.
Ferrari  (System | Reviews | Threads | Answers | This Thread)


05-01-11   john scofield is my favorite. i've seen him in concert. won ...   Foster_9

05-01-11   Not sure real sure the "all music is subjective" s ...   Duanegoosen

05-01-11   The top of my list includes, joe pass, kenny burrell, wes mo ...   Charles1dad

05-01-11   Lenny breau   Taylor514

05-01-11   I'm tempted to say it starts and ends with django, but duane ...   Martykl

05-01-11   For the complexity of playing style i think stanley jordan i ...   Footsurg

05-01-11   Fz is the best everywhere not only in jazz   Marakanetz

05-02-11   I think of some of the guys mentioned as fusion guitarists a ...   Rja

05-02-11   until jazz is over,or finished (which is pretty unlikely co ...   Ths364

05-02-11   Duanegoosen, [not sure real sure the "all music is subj ...   Orpheus10

05-02-11   My favourites are joe pass and grant green. glen   Gkella

05-02-11   "best ever" makes a catchy thread title. tho, the ...   Isochronism

05-02-11   On the django gypsy jazz/swing branch, stochelo rosenberg a ...   Samhar

05-02-11   Sam ... thanks for that link , it was excellent . also had a ...   Tmsorosk

05-02-11   Isochronism, the truth be told; almost every guitarist menti ...   Orpheus10

05-02-11   Orpheus, i love them all! of course, when i pick up/plug in ...   Isochronism

05-02-11   Emily remler "east to wes". yes!   Isochronism

05-02-11   Tmsorosk, both always put a smile on my face, glad you enjoy ...   Samhar

05-02-11   Nice one orphy... especially the stop sign, (talk to the han ...   Duanegoosen

05-03-11   John mclaughlin. but i don't care about his music after 1992 ...   Inna

05-03-11   Inna, although you mentioned al di meola, you didn't go into ...   Orpheus10

05-03-11   Well (imo) ivan 'boogaloo joe' jones has the best name.   Jaybo

05-03-11   You tube: "john mclaughlin tonight show". he does ...   Isochronism

05-03-11   Pat martino - he is "twice" better than the others ...   Kijanki

05-03-11   this thread has attracted some of the most knowledgeable &q ...   Orpheus10

05-03-11   Don't forget those guys who can play in almost any style, li ...   Ptmconsulting

05-03-11   In my more traditional list wes is tops. great to see lenny ...   Slothman

05-03-11   For my taste al di meola's best and great work is "ciel ...   Inna

05-04-11   Inna, i agree in regard to "cielo e terra" as his ...   Orpheus10

05-04-11   Pat metheny's is much more than jazz guitarist but orchestra ...   Marakanetz

05-04-11   If anyone is interested in paco de lucia but not well famili ...   Inna

05-05-11   Don't forget egberto gismonte everyone. also an awesome comp ...   Ptmconsulting

05-05-11   I only know egberto as a composer, never heard him play. i b ...   Inna

05-05-11   i was a "brazilian" in my life before this one. a ...   Orpheus10

05-05-11   Brazilians do know a thing or two about rhythm. melodies are ...   Inna

05-05-11   Orpheus10, have you tried charlie byrd yet? he played a lot ...   Newbee

05-06-11   charlie byrd first came to my attention when he did "j ...   Orpheus10

05-06-11   Any particular album by gismonti is a must have? that brazil ...   Inna

05-07-11   Danny gatton "hot rod guitar" (2 cd set) other tit ...   Isochronism

05-08-11   Redneck jazz is a stunner. iirc, there was also a live vers ...   Martykl

05-08-11   inna, "sol do meio dia" is one of the most beauti ...   Orpheus10

05-08-11   orpheus10, i must say that is very insightful.   Foster_9

05-10-11   foster_9, i consider that quite a compliment, especially s ...   Orpheus10

05-12-11   My favorite is burrell,like very much grant green and p.de l ...   Alexatpos

05-25-11   Iso, your post motivated me to wade thru the pile and pull ...   Martykl

05-25-11   I'm too hard on jazz guitar, in general. i've always heard ...   Paanders

05-26-11   Anything but like charlie parker; i hate this. you can't rea ...   Inna

05-26-11   And also, from mclaughlin's album "the promise" th ...   Inna

05-26-11   I like several (jim hall, kenny burrell, joe pass, john jorg ...   Rockadanny

05-27-11   Now that we have thoroughly covered the best, i would like t ...   Orpheus10

06-01-11   Jimi hendrix comes to mind when i think 'who's the best guit ...   Daveyf

06-01-11   i saw albert king live, he was a big impressive man whose g ...   Orpheus10

06-01-11   And now, back to jazz ...   Rockadanny

06-04-11   rockadanny, i have the same problem with wes and grant; the ...   Orpheus10

06-14-11   gabor szabo is one fantastic guitarist. he must be included ...   Orpheus10

06-14-11   "martin taylor is one of the most awesome solo guitar p ...   Kijanki

08-14-11   Ptmconsulting: "george benson (when he actually plays)& ...   Isochronism

08-14-11   My favorite is joe pass.   Roxy54

08-28-11   Wes montgomery,thumb,no pick,check out"tear it down&quo ...   Playpen

08-29-11   I put in my two cents above, i just wanted to say this is an ...   Rja

08-29-11   Still alive and kicking: tuck andress !   Peterb

08-29-11   Playpen the first two are for you, the last one is for me ...   Orpheus10

09-06-11   Http://youtu.be/akw40qceql8 orpheus,i realy appreciate your ...   Alexatpos

09-06-11   You tube: "danny gatton at gallagher's". there!   Isochronism

09-07-11   Alexatpos, while i like many great guitarist a lot; grant gr ...   Orpheus10

09-07-11   Orpheus,yes i know,thats way i posted this,hope you like it. ...   Alexatpos

09-07-11   alexatpos, this is one of my favorites by kenny burrell, i' ...   Orpheus10

09-07-11   orpheus10, i like your statement about jazz becoming " ...   Ths364

09-10-11   No best!! otherwise, i highly recommend kevin eubanks " ...   Isochronism

09-12-11   Ptmconsulting, and all george benson fans; he is by far the ...   Orpheus10


  Post your response
Subject


Your response

No html, but you may use markup tags


Username
Members only

Password