AudiogoN
Search Buy Sell Learn MyPage
 Learn > Forums > Music > 1244926021  Start New Thread | Log In | Bookmark This
  Music and politics
A post yesterday about U2 prompted me to listen to them today. And one comment from yesterday got me to thinking. The author wrote dismissively that they should "keep their politics to themselves." (Those may or may not have been the exact words, but that gets to the point.) As I've been listening this afternoon, I've thought: I'm neither a born-again Christian nor a political leftie, but I do love this band. And then I thought further: If I listened only to bands or singer-songwriters whose politics were like mine, I surely wouldn't spin a whole lot of recordings. (For the record, I consider myself a radically pragmatic centrist with occasional libertarian leanings. Got any bands who'd fill that bill?) I care about the music, and not about what the people making that music happen to believe. Am I alone in this? Do others dismiss certain artists because of their politics -- or religion or the kind of car they drive or whatever else?
Hodu  (Threads | Answers | This Thread)

06-13-09
  Responses (1-54 of 54)
Click title to read one, or click date to read all below it.

06-13-09   Music mixed with religion and politics goes back to the begi ...   Jaybo

06-13-09   I could care less about an artists politics or religious bel ...   Cruz123

06-13-09   I agree with cruz123. i get very, very tired of being hit o ...   Kurt_tank

06-13-09   U2 has been leaning to the left for almost thirty years. if ...   Grimace

06-13-09   If one wishes to avoid music with political statements (or a ...   Tvad

06-13-09   I attended a roger waters show which was excellent until he ...   Entrope

06-13-09   Whoa! artists getting political because they lost their tale ...   Ogsarg

06-13-09   Musicians who use concerts as political platforms are well k ...   Tvad

06-13-09   I'm complainin' to the 'american federation of musicians'... ...   Jaybo

06-14-09   Tvad is right we know what they believe, so the choice is ou ...   Theo

06-14-09   I am no politcially correct person, but i agree with both si ...   Fmpnd

06-13-09   I think there is a significant difference between putting po ...   Markphd

06-14-09   This was my response to a similar post back in '06, but even ...   Jackaroe

06-14-09   I wish i had time to comment on this thread, but i volunteer ...   Dcrugby

06-14-09   Agree or disagree with their messages - the one thing you ca ...   Grimace

06-14-09   Shut up and sing. thank you very much.   Audiofeil

06-14-09   I agree with markphd when he says: "i think there is a ...   Minkwelder

06-14-09   I listen to music to be entertained. any musician that think ...   Zenblaster

06-14-09   yes, because i support their first amendment rights. if yo ...   Tvad

06-14-09   Most artists are progressive to begin with,whether they are ...   Route9

06-14-09   I personally hate it when foriegn bands critisize the us pol ...   Joeylawn36111

06-14-09   I love politically slanted music. the world would be poorer ...   Bongofury

06-14-09   Bongo- did you drop $100 on the concert ticket to hear an a ...   Entrope

06-14-09   Tvad, i respect your opinion and usually agree with most of ...   Fmpnd

06-14-09   We'd all be listening to pat boone and watching daniel boone ...   Jaybo

06-14-09   Fmpnd, do you believe kvetching about it here is going to st ...   Tvad

06-14-09   It's apparent that many people don't want artists making art ...   Onhwy61

06-14-09   They (the musicians) have the freedom to say what they want ...   Rja

06-14-09   How and the hell did you last few posters devolve into think ...   Fmpnd

06-15-09   How does an artist that does only instrumental music challen ...   Entrope

06-15-09   I don't believe most posters here advocate censorship. imo, ...   Audiofeil

06-15-09   i didn't say that the challenge has to be political. as a m ...   Onhwy61

06-15-09   Entrope, without coming within a mile of this debate, i onl ...   Martykl

06-15-09   Marty- point taken. i was referring to actions within the c ...   Entrope

06-15-09   First,let me say that i respect anyones thoughts or beliefs ...   Tpreaves

06-15-09   Ussr used to have problems with some purely instrumental stu ...   Rja

06-15-09   Ah yes onhhwy61, you really are something. you have no idea ...   Fmpnd

06-16-09   Rhetorically speaking, are foriegn bands/singers protected b ...   Joeylawn36111

06-16-09   Entrope i used to roadie for the clash in 1982. i would ex ...   Bongofury

06-16-09   Great art generally has a 'point of view'. you don't 'have t ...   Jaybo

06-16-09   Bongo- the key as you stated "as long as its in the mu ...   Entrope

06-17-09   The arrogance of you liberals to have all of the decent musi ...   Dcrugby

06-26-09   Fmpnd, got your e-mail. it really wasn't necessary on your ...   Onhwy61

06-26-09   That guy should have posted 25 years ago. maybe he was too y ...   Cyclonicman

06-29-09   Beethoven for more conservative right winger. brahms, mozar ...   50svinyl

10-09-09   I not care much about a musicians politics. i might not list ...   Chatta

10-10-09   I have an idea. the musicians who want to rant about there p ...   Ozzy

10-10-09   Ozzy there is a photo on the cover on the new woodie guthri ...   Bongofury

10-10-09   Rock musicians are in most cases under-educated, over confin ...   Macdadtexas

10-10-09   I find musicians, on the whole, are bright, talented and har ...   Shadorne

10-10-09   Bongofury, i think it is you who has it all wrong. i really ...   Ozzy

10-17-09   I dont care about politics, the music is the only way to mak ...   Singleendedsingle

10-17-09   If the money was in right wing politics hollyood would be bu ...   Zenblaster

10-17-09: Entrope
Money is in right wing politics. Listen to your AM radio.
Artists have less political impact than Right leaning radio hosts.

Artist seem to be less astute politically and cause driven looking through a microscope rather than a fisheye lens. I also believe Fox News is the #1 new network which translates into $$$.

Entrope  (System | Reviews | Threads | Answers | This Thread)



  Post your response
Subject


Your response

No html, but you may use markup tags


Username
Members only

Password