AudiogoN
Search Buy Sell Learn MyPage
 Learn > Forums > Music > 1120231330  Start New Thread | Log In | Bookmark This
  An observation about "Modern" classical music.
As I sat in my car, waiting for my wife as usual, I listened to a local classical music station which happened to be playing some "modern" music. I don't like it, being an old fart who likes Mozart and his ilk. But, as I had nothing else to do, I tried to appreciate what I heard. No luck, but I did notice something I have experienced before but never thought about. At the end, there was a dead silence of 3 to 5 seconds before audience applause. This never happens with, for example, Mozart where the final notes never get a chance to decay before the applause and Bravos. Obviously (IMHO) the music was so hard to "follow" that the audience were not sure it was over until nothing happened for a while.

I know that some guys like this music, but haven't you noticed this dead time? How do you explain it?
Eldartford  (Reviews | Threads | Answers | This Thread)

07-01-05
  Responses (51-100 of 124)
Click title to read one, or click date to read all below it.

12-03-05   I'm listening to penderecki's auschwitz oratorio as we speak ...   Lousyreeds1

12-03-05   I've been reading this thread for some time without commenti ...   Albertporter

12-03-05   Shubertmaniac..."inventive" is great, but the real ...   Eldartford

12-03-05   Aaaah, it's refreshing to see a thread about the substance o ...   Bojack

12-03-05   Eldartford: i see a lot of hypocrisy in stating your musical ...   Lousyreeds1

12-03-05   A reader doesnt like dante "divine comedy" or does ...   Seurat

12-03-05   Lousyreeds1...i don't think that i ever said that my prefere ...   Eldartford

12-03-05   "this thread is supposed to be about thoughtful analysi ...   Lousyreeds1

12-03-05   Sorry, but not every detail carries such weighty "meani ...   Arkprof

12-03-05   Lousyreeds1...if you will check my original posting you will ...   Eldartford

12-03-05   On the contrary, i'm doing everything i can to suggest ways ...   Lousyreeds1

12-03-05   One fench piano teacher said: "music should not come f ...   Marakanetz

12-04-05   Marakanetz...i don't claim extensive knowledge about musical ...   Eldartford

12-05-05   The question of art is a valid one particularly in a post mo ...   Shubertmaniac

12-05-05   Wnyc-fm (93.9) plays modern classical music. wkcr (89.9) co ...   Theduke

12-08-05   I just happened on this thread during a break from work. ea ...   Johnrob

12-09-05   Eldartford, we're in the world of different events and subj ...   Marakanetz

12-09-05   Marakanetz... i like "peter and the wolf". maybe t ...   Eldartford

12-09-05   Eldartford: not all but 99% of modern classical music is str ...   Shubertmaniac

12-09-05   The problem is that as the composers use the 12 tone scale w ...   Robm321

12-09-05   Shubertmaniac: no, serialism is by definition atonal. it ha ...   Lousyreeds1

12-09-05   Lousyreeds1...on a different subject..i am curious, about yo ...   Eldartford

12-09-05   Can't sing?   Lousyreeds1

12-09-05   That last post from lousyreeds cuts to the heart of this iss ...   Brownsfan

12-10-05   Hi brownsfan, fantastic post! i've never heard of lohrmann, ...   Lousyreeds1

12-10-05   I have three recommendations for modern classical music that ...   Johnrob

12-10-05   Lousyreeds, i moved from ohio to indianapolis about 15 year ...   Brownsfan

12-10-05   Lousyreeds1...vocal cords are sometimes called "reeds&q ...   Eldartford

12-11-05   Well in that case i should call myself lousyreed2. great p ...   Robm321

12-12-05   Just a quick note of agreement on the shostakovich quartets ...   Opalchip

12-13-05   For shostakovich quartets try the borodin q version on melod ...   Gregm

12-13-05   I've read up on serial/12 tone - they were in the same chapt ...   Robm321

12-17-05   Robm, robm, robm! i can't give you details on john adams cr ...   Brownsfan

12-18-05   I am really happy that some people do like "modern" ...   Eldartford

12-18-05   Ever listened to the "hoe down" from copland's &qu ...   Lousyreeds1

12-18-05   lousyreeds1...yes i have heard copland"s "rodeo&q ...   Eldartford

12-19-05   Eldarford your initial post didn't state the intent of aski ...   Johnrob

12-19-05   John...i don't know why you and other modernists assume that ...   Eldartford

12-19-05: Johnrob
Eldartford,

Sorry if I assumed incorrectly, it wasn't obvious from your posts.

So, then am I to assume that you have listened to Gorecki's Third or Arvo Part's Cantus In Memoriam Benjamin Britten - Fratres - Tabula Rasa - Spiegel im Spiegel? If not, my challenge remains.

What other apsects of modern music do you object to?

John

Johnrob  (Threads | Answers | This Thread)


12-19-05   John...my initial posting describes how it evolved from a li ...   Eldartford

12-19-05   "if i can't hum it, i don't like it." all i can s ...   Lousyreeds1

12-19-05   "atonal" has been used by bach and all the rest. i ...   Robm321

12-20-05   Robm321...you are absolutely correct about beethoven's late ...   Eldartford

12-21-05   Lol eldartford - how can i argue with that. the more he lost ...   Robm321

12-21-05   Robm321 also listen to speigal im speigal. one of the best ...   Johnrob

12-22-05   John, i have listened to speigal and agree with you. i thi ...   Robm321

12-25-05   A funny thing happened yesterday. a radio station that i oft ...   Eldartford

12-25-05   Says a lot more about you as a listener than about "'th ...   Lousyreeds1

12-25-05   Lousyreeds1...i can agree with that. it says that i am not t ...   Eldartford

12-26-05   Please, eldartford. you're quite proud of the fact that you ...   Lousyreeds1

12-26-05   Lousyreeds1...as the saying goes..."if i said that i wa ...   Eldartford

12-26-05   If you're going to post snyde comments about what you call ' ...   Lousyreeds1

12-26-05   Lousyreeds1..."that" music was an acknowledgement ...   Eldartford

12-27-05   I agree with eldartford. no offense to those that like that ...   Robm321

12-28-05   Eldartford, the ingenious subtlety of your prose was lost on ...   Lousyreeds1

12-28-05   Lousyreeds1...serious question...do you feel that there are ...   Eldartford

12-29-05   "i like music if i can hum it" - this narrows your ...   Seurat

12-29-05   i'll take a delayed audience response any day of the week t ...   Themadmilkman

12-29-05   Seurat...beethoven "moonlight" sonatta and the fir ...   Eldartford

12-29-05   Eldartford, i love classical music including contemporary cl ...   Seurat

12-29-05   Eldartford, "don't we all narrow our musical choices t ...   Brownsfan

12-29-05   Brownsfan...following "quit after peter and the wolf&qu ...   Eldartford

12-30-05   Eldartford, it's because you don't understand the peas ;) ...   Robm321

04-12-07   Today's local newspaper reports that the boston symphony orc ...   Eldartford

04-12-07   Once in bam i and my other 2 friends had 2 tickets extra to ...   Marakanetz

04-13-07   Marakanetz...interestingly most of the tanglewood audience s ...   Eldartford

04-13-07   i would love to see koyanisquatsi, especially stoned! oops ...   Chadnliz

04-13-07   Hello, i would like to see it stoned also, but i sure would ...   Acoustat6

04-14-07   you bring the papers...........   Chadnliz

04-14-07   Ah!...now i understand why i can't appreciate contemporary m ...   Eldartford

04-14-07   "mmmmmmmmmmmmmm cheese and crackers" (homer simps ...   Chadnliz

04-14-07   Chad... durin' munch? i wasn't stoned and was enjoying but i ...   Marakanetz

04-14-07   i guess we are "high" class stoners, but to be ho ...   Chadnliz

04-22-07   Eldartford, can i make a music recommendation? "the es ...   Audphile1


< Prev 1 | 2

  Post your response
Subject


Your response

No html, but you may use markup tags


Username
Members only

Password