AudiogoN
Search Buy Sell Learn MyPage
 Learn > Forums > Analog > 1257372812  Start New Thread | Log In | Bookmark This
  Phono stages belong to which tier?
I feel the phono stage is the most critical component in an analog system since it is an important part of the source. Which phono stages have you heard and in which tier would they fall in 1st 2nd or 3rd?
From reading the threads here: aesthetix, manley, lamm, fm acoustics, einstein would probably fall in the 1st.
Please include stages that have been listened to extensively and those that have been heard breifly.
Pedrillo  (System | Threads | Answers | This Thread)

11-04-09
  Responses (1-55 of 55)
Click title to read one, or click date to read all below it.

11-04-09   Right off the bat, this is all highly subjective, and based ...   Kurt_tank

11-04-09   Agree with kurt tank, highly subjective and debateable. the ...   Nkj

11-04-09   Analogue playback is as volatile as speakers. so it's tier 1 ...   Marakanetz

11-05-09   I think there is more of a continuum than strict tiers - imo ...   Jtimothya

11-05-09   Where would you guys place the linto?   Stratguy

11-05-09   i would also add to the top teir the allnic h 3000, with it ...   Logenn

11-05-09   Doshi alaap, tier 1+. oh! sorry. the alaap is not on your li ...   Dan_ed

11-05-09   Those of you judging the rhea,are you using the latest " ...   Mred

11-05-09   I am reluctant to "rate" any particular product -- ...   Larryi

11-05-09   Nice to see all the recomendations for whest ;)   Rap_hawthorn

11-05-09   Take a listen to the vas 1 pre-amp. as all have commented, ...   Buconero117

11-05-09   I haven't heard what many here would consider "top tier ...   Dodgealum

11-05-09   Thank you for your responses. one thing i have noticed, that ...   Pedrillo

11-05-09   Logenn, can you compare the sonic qualities of the lamm lp2 ...   Jj2468

11-06-09   Not sure about top tier, but in my system the manley steelhe ...   Tom_hankins

11-06-09   Pedrillo, a lot of fine phono stages listed here, but, i wo ...   Larryi

11-06-09   I owned a manley steelhead until i got my mcintosh c2300, th ...   Tjnif

11-06-09   I would probably suggest adding the hagerman trumpet to the ...   Ptmconsulting

11-06-09   Add a new one to the list paul hynes phono for those that h ...   Musicfile

11-06-09   hmmm are you splitting between mm & mc phono stages? ...   Downunder

11-06-09   Add zanden 1200 mk 2 (or 3) to the list. in my book surely a ...   Nilthepill

11-06-09   I have had quite a few phono stages over the years in my sys ...   Radicalsteve

11-06-09   First tier class a asr basis exclusive 2010 or any prior v ...   Fm540i

11-07-09   one of my audiobuddies owned a asr basis exclusive. he so ...   Downunder

11-07-09   Anyone heard the wavestream kinetics phono stage?   Aoliviero

11-07-09   I tried ear 324 and asthetix rhea with my asr ii exclusive. ...   Suteetat

11-08-09   Jj2482, the lamm with westerm electric nos 417's is splendi ...   Logenn

11-08-09   Aoliviero, i have owned the lamm, steelhead, a ...   Lula

11-08-09   Tom evans would probably be here as well like the groove x o ...   Nolitan

11-10-09   I'm been running the wavestream kinetics phono stage and pre ...   Gerrym5

11-12-09   So would it be safe to say these are in the top tier? aesthe ...   Pedrillo

11-12-09   Dear pedrillo: i don't know what precise information you are ...   Rauliruegas

11-12-09   Raul, thanks for asking. i am about to make a purchase of a ...   Pedrillo

11-12-09   Raul, how many stages do you have in the essential and how ...   Perrew

11-12-09   Dear perrew: two independent stages configured as need it: 2 ...   Rauliruegas

11-13-09   Raul, thank you for answering. when you say i can have 80db ...   Perrew

11-13-09   Dear perrew: remember that the essential 3160 is a phonoline ...   Rauliruegas

11-16-09: Aceboympk
Analog setup:
- Dynavector Te Kaitora (not Rua)
www.needledoctor
- Avid Diva II
www.musicdirect
- Origin Live Encounter Mk2 arm

Amp: Yamamoto A-08S
www.6moons

Linstage Pre-amp: Canary CA-903
www.6moons

Currently I have a Canary CA-401 phono stage that I enjoy a lot, but I'm looking for a more quiet phono stage. In fact, dead quiet would be great.

Most knowledgeable Agon members suggest matching the phono stage based on components and preferences, so I listed my components hoping you guys can help.

My budget is between $1k-$2k. Because of my amp and line stage being tube based, I'm REALLY needing a dead quiet phono stage without sacrificing performance. I want a little more speed, focus and tightness, without diminishing the soundstage, range or textures of the Canary.

I'm sure there are trade offs, but I'd appreciate some suggestions. I read through all of the phono stages listed in everyone's post so I have some more information. But, synergy is really important when it comes to matching components directly. The Canary is great, but a little too noisy with the rest of my tube gear and I think balancing out my tube gear with a SS phono MAY be the way to go, instead of overemphasizing the "tube" sound with everything being tubes. Make sense?

Thanks,
Mark

Aceboympk  (Threads | Answers | This Thread)


11-16-09   2nd hand pass xono - perfect choice   Downunder

11-16-09   Pedrillo, i have the whest 30rdt, which i utilize with a vp ...   Ebe

12-12-09   Aceboympk i was going through a similar search and finally ...   Samhar

12-26-09   Would like to add the tron seven to this list! awesome phono ...   Nolitan

12-27-09   Another vote for the tron seven! top class sound, great buil ...   Topoxforddoc

12-27-09   i have the whest audio ps30 rdt too.. with tw acoustic rave ...   Curio

12-29-09   Don't agree phono stages are the most critical component in ...   Jimpcn

12-30-09   My ranking - (1) phono (2) cart (3) tonearm/wire (4) tt t ...   Shsohis

01-17-10   Has anyone heard the walker audio reference phono second edi ...   Krc

01-23-10   Hey curio, thanks for quoting me in your response! i'm sitt ...   Ebe

02-11-10   If one is serious about the goal of having a hi fidelity, hi ...   Vertigo

02-12-10   02-11-10: vertigo ......and no component should be overlooke ...   Audiofeil

02-24-10   I think it is fair to say that my opinion that no one item s ...   Vertigo

02-26-10   Vertigo, i partially agree. i say that for a reason, here's ...   Pedrillo

03-15-10   Anyone have information about the new parasound jc-3? for $ ...   Dodgealum

03-27-10   aesthetix io alaap mkii allnic h3000 asr exclusive atma-sph ...   Pedrillo

03-27-10   John curl is being john curl, that's a positive, ringing out ...   Gerrym5


  Post your response
Subject


Your response

No html, but you may use markup tags


Username
Members only

Password