AudiogoN
Search Buy Sell Learn MyPage
 Learn > Forums > Analog > 1200667355  Start New Thread | Log In | Bookmark This
  Graham Phantom vs Triplaner
Wondering about the sonic traits of both these arms compared to each other.

- which one has deeper bass,
- which one has the warmer (relative) balance
- which one is compatible with more cartridges
- which one has the better more organic midrange
- which one has the greater treble detail.
- which one plays music better ( yes this is a more subjective question ).
- which one goes better with say the TW acoustic raven TT.
Downunder  (System | Threads | Answers | This Thread)

01-18-08
  Responses (101-150 of 166)
Click title to read one, or click date to read all below it.

03-03-08   Sirspeedy i haven't ignored your request for a review of the ...   Halcro

03-03-08   Halcro,now a 12 inch davinci too? you're such a tease! -:)   Sirspeedy

03-05-08   Mr mai does not give or loan tonearms. there were so many at ...   Zieman

03-06-08   Good point, z. of course one should also consider that the ...   Swampwalker

03-06-08   The common use of a particular component at ces or any show ...   Larryi

03-06-08   Guys, i have spent alot of time with mr mai. he seems to hav ...   Zieman

03-06-08   z i agree. tri mai is a very nice guy. i met him at ces ...   Downunder

03-06-08   D, i forget which room i saw the rim in, but the two guys sh ...   Zieman

03-07-08   Larry, yes, mr wilson puts the stuff out there. he can affor ...   Zieman

03-07-08: Larryi
Yes, Tri Mai is a nice guy, and so was the founder Herb Papier. I've also met Victor Conti from Vector. It seems like a lot of the people involved in tonearm design are great guys who are passionate about their work.

I am a bit leery of the whole business of people needing to establish which is "the best," treating everything as some kind of competition. I've heard a lot of different and good setups using a wide range of arms -- Shroeder Reference, Kuzma (tangential/air bearing), Vector, Naim Aro, SME, Moerch, Graham Phantom, etc. I've heard the same cartridge (Transfiguration Orpheus) in different arms in the same system.

As a general observation, when one is using an arm that is compatible with a particular cartridge, among very well designed arms, the differences are slight as compared to the difference in sound from changing cartridges or the turntable itself. That actually argues in favor of the easy-to-use arms (Graham, Triplanar). I say "slight" in comparison, but, differences are notable and certainly worth considering. But, these kinds of differences fall into the category of system tuning, personal preferences, etc. and so nothing suggests one is better than the other.

Larryi  (System | Threads | Answers | This Thread)


03-07-08   D, harry is one of this industries true characters. loves hi ...   Zieman

03-07-08   Larry,you are "sooooo" right!!!   Sirspeedy

03-07-08   Right on larry. the time i spent with aj this year was a hoo ...   Zieman

03-07-08   z the rim drive from memory was being use on mike herro ...   Downunder

03-07-08   doh!!!!! i mean keith herron's room   Downunder

03-07-08   D, these guys must have been on herron. ha! there i go, crac ...   Zieman

03-08-08   Z 312s in part 2 with the brinkman, consonance & cartridg ...   Downunder

03-08-08   I am amazed from some "experiences" here, because ...   Thomasheisig

03-08-08   D, my bad. i was looking for a title reading 312s review. i ...   Zieman

03-08-08   Hey thomas,i think what mas "meant" was that at so ...   Sirspeedy

03-08-08   Btw thomas,i believe i have on "many occassions" m ...   Sirspeedy

03-09-08   Sir, huh? from what band? the comedian? bill maher, maybe. b ...   Zieman

03-09-08   Z...analytical,and funny!that's all.   Sirspeedy

03-10-08   Sir, i know you added extra letters to anal, to be nice. tha ...   Zieman

03-10-08   Well, miller is a bit obnoxious too,but i really like the gu ...   Sirspeedy

03-10-08   Sir, you had me at anlytical. z.   Zieman

03-10-08   Thomas, you are the best placed among us to comment on the d ...   Halcro

03-12-08   Thomas, i second halcro's request for you to share your exp ...   Logenn

03-12-08   The triplanar vii is a excellent unit with its good cable an ...   Thomasheisig

03-12-08   Thank you thomas. excellent information!   Halcro

03-13-08   Thomas, we hugely appreciate your sharing with us your expe ...   Logenn

03-13-08   I have to commend thomas on the observation that triplanar h ...   Zieman

03-13-08   Thomas, thanks for sharing your observations. it appears t ...   Larryi

03-13-08   Larryi, what were your impressions of the phantom/vector/ti ...   Piedpiper

03-14-08   Piedpiper, i own a titan/vector/basis debut combination fee ...   Larryi

03-14-08   Larry,as you probably know,i have an orpheus.my dear friend ...   Sirspeedy

03-14-08   Thanks larryi. all too rare to hear such straight forward co ...   Piedpiper

07-10-09   Hello folks, i have used the graham phantom-2 now for about ...   Aoliviero

07-10-09   Andrew, long time no hear. guess you've been enjoying too m ...   Dougdeacon

07-10-09   Hi andrew, thanks for the report. glad you're still with u ...   Dan_ed

07-10-09   Dear aoliviero: as good and different as both tonearms are e ...   Rauliruegas

07-10-09   I too have never experienced a 'drift' in vtf. i have 3 arms ...   Atmasphere

07-10-09   Hey doug, dan and raul yes it has been a long time. i hope ...   Aoliviero

07-11-09   Nothing drifty here. excepting the proprietor. dealer disc ...   Audiofeil

07-11-09   Hey audiofeil, thats funny. you're a real joker:). which aud ...   Aoliviero

07-12-09   Some think, that the triplanar is still in the same class th ...   Syntax

07-12-09   And the verbal floggings will continue until tonearm morale ...   Dan_ed

07-12-09   Hi dan, i agree but i see it from a different view: i have a ...   Syntax

07-12-09   Hello me mateies i've googeled looking for the graham p2 ton ...   Stltrains

07-12-09   Mike, talk to dan_ed...he's already there with his tp (and ...   Palasr

07-12-09   So, lots of tri-planar owners the talk about the tiny cartri ...   Jfrech

07-12-09   Dan, i agree, the p2 sould be better if it had a continuous ...   Aoliviero

07-12-09   Aoliviero and syntax: have you tried either of the continuu ...   Jimjoyce25

07-13-09   Jfrech, it is not just tp owners. i also own a basis vector. ...   Dan_ed

07-13-09   Jimjoyce25, i have not tried the continuum. halcro has some ...   Aoliviero

07-23-09   I wonder if any of you have given any more thought to the in ...   Aoliviero

07-23-09   Can i answer with another question? why do graham arms have ...   Dan_ed

07-23-09   The answer is: because it is black :-)   Syntax

07-23-09   But what about the gold trim, syntax? :-) should we also p ...   Dan_ed

07-23-09   That's for colored reproduction systems :-)   Syntax

07-23-09   Dan what you are getting at is that the arm tube alone does ...   Aoliviero

07-23-09   Well it is probably a lot more complicated than all of this! ...   Aoliviero

07-23-09   Grasshopper! you have plucked the pebble from my palm! :-):- ...   Dan_ed

07-23-09   Seriously, and just on a layman's observation, the applicati ...   Dan_ed

07-23-09   Dan is that jorma k? is it acoustic and on lp? i saw hot t ...   Aoliviero

07-24-09   Yes, koukonen. folks who own the cd seem to be very happy wi ...   Dan_ed


< Prev 1 | 2 | 3

  Post your response
Subject


Your response

No html, but you may use markup tags


Username
Members only

Password