AudiogoN
Search Buy Sell Learn MyPage
 Learn > Forums > Analog > 1152804807  Start New Thread | Log In | Bookmark This
  Analog vs. CDP: A fair comparison?
Ok, in summary, I'm planning on selling my Cary 303/300 and taking the funds and buying a TT rig including Table, Arm & Cartridge. I'll worry about the phono stage, record cleaning machine, etc. later.

Assuming I get $2,500 from the CDP, will I be able to get a used rig that will at least match the sound quality? Assume also that I will have a phono stage budget of $1,000.

Rest of the system if Cary 300SEI.

Is this a fair comparison? Or, will the sound just be different (i.e. tubes vs ss).

thanx much
Pawlowski6132  (System | Threads | Answers | This Thread)

07-13-06
  Responses (1-48 of 48)
Click title to read one, or click date to read all below it.

07-13-06   Personally i think you should not look at this in a piecemea ...   Kurt_tank

07-13-06   For an informed (if opinionated) view of your situation, try ...   Musicslug

07-13-06   The largest cost for either format is not in equipment, but ...   Onhwy61

07-13-06   I agree with the others when they wonder if you already own ...   Tarsando

07-13-06   A record doctor cleaning kit, a decca brush and a zerostat s ...   Jalanc42069

07-13-06: Dirtyragamuffin
I disagree on the software concerns--vinyl is very abundant and can be much cheaper than CDs as used--just make sure you have a good record cleaning machine in this case. As far as specialty heavyweight vinyl pressings, they don't cost any more than specialty gold/remastered/diamond studded rewhatevered CD pressings and sometimes less. I also think the benefits are greater but then, I've never owned a really super high end digital rig.

There are a few issues you should consider: is the music you want more, as, or less available on vinyl than digital? Are you willing to go through turntable setup and periodic maintenance? Like the others have already brought up, how big is your digital collection and how will you play them? I would think it would make more sense to add a vinyl rig to your current system rather than replace your digital outright--unless I'm missing something?

Also, be warned that vinyl is different--better or worse is entirely up to you. Some people like me don't mind some pops and click in older records, others seems to have minor coronaries over it. By nature, records are inconsistent. New domestic pressings in particular are often a bit warped and sometimes pressing techniques are hardly impressive. Vinyl can be a mixed bag. Compact discs are at least physically more consistent--mastering jobs are of course a different story. If you plan to buy new domestic vinyl pressings or poorly stored old "garage sale finds," I would recommend you figure some kind of record warp correction into the turntable rig you choose. There are several option: vacuum platter systems as with SOTA, periphery rings, or standalone record flatters (I have zero experience with machines that purport to flat records but they are out there). Also make sure you have a good record clamp.

Dirtyragamuffin  (System | Threads | Answers | This Thread)


07-13-06   I am not sure if you are aware that you cannot play vinyl di ...   Sidssp

07-13-06   Agree one thousand percent with onhwy61. pawlowski, are you ...   Zaikesman

07-13-06   Yeah, i can't imagine being without both cdp and vinyl. ther ...   Dan_ed

07-14-06   No! period end of story! i was extremely hesistant to go ana ...   Mechans

07-14-06   Are you getting rid of your cdp because you think--and heard ...   Justubes

07-14-06   First of all, thank you everybody for all your thoughtful re ...   Pawlowski6132

07-14-06   Oh, and justubes, yes, i've heard lots of people say that, i ...   Pawlowski6132

07-15-06   Pawlowski612, thanks for providing more info on where you'r ...   Dougdeacon

07-15-06   I got back into analog a few months ago on a lark after buyi ...   Maineiac

07-15-06   You sound like a collector rather than a user. imho go for i ...   Shadorne

07-15-06   Thanks pawlowski for answering my question. i admit i can't ...   Zaikesman

07-15-06   Thanx zaikesman for what i think sounds like a left-handed w ...   Pawlowski6132

07-15-06   Back-handed. i have nothing against my left-handed brothers ...   Zaikesman

07-17-06   Don't get rid of the cdp. go the 500-1000 dollar complete t ...   Johnnyb1

07-17-06   Hi paw - the 303/300 is a very good cdp, particularly if you ...   Jwpstayman

07-17-06   It all depends on what is important to you. if absence of su ...   Eldartford

07-17-06   Eldee: i take it you mean "never been to nirvana". ...   Zaikesman

07-17-06   Zaikesman...i used to think my lp equipment was ok until i g ...   Eldartford

07-18-06   E: i think choice of program material also has something to ...   Zaikesman

07-18-06   Zaikesman...you are correct in that program material which i ...   Eldartford

07-20-06   Dear pawlowski6132 : i think that kurt_tank put everything i ...   Rauliruegas

07-21-06   Run both worlds.... you gotta keep a cdp no doubt, sometimes ...   Undertow

07-21-06   If you're into the sensual part of the hobby, then there's n ...   Ptmconsulting

07-21-06   Will i think an input from the digital camp is in order. ar ...   Artizen65

07-25-06   I have been reading this tread with great interest. i too a ...   Billt1

07-25-06   Billt1, in one sense there is no reason to "worry" ...   Dougdeacon

07-25-06   Don't do it bill! don't listen to the siren's song! contact ...   Dan_ed

07-25-06   I agree with doug in that the worry should be minimal. if a ...   Maineiac

07-25-06   This thread has kind of turned into the first and only threa ...   Dicobrazil

07-26-06   Excellent advice from maineiac re: buying used. audiogon and ...   Dougdeacon

07-26-06   Great advice from all, thank you. i do buy allot of used gea ...   Billt1

07-26-06   Whatever else you do - bribe doug to set your table up   Ndoshi

07-26-06   Billt1, why didn't you just buy a used cary amp and new (nos ...   Pawlowski6132

07-26-06   “billt1, why didn't you just buy a used cary amp and new (n ...   Billt1

07-26-06   The one aspect that i discovered about vinyl which was total ...   Maineiac

07-31-06   I was in this boat a year or so ago, though i was not intere ...   Zanth

07-31-06   Hey zanth, thanx. that's a pretty encouraging thread! and, i ...   Pawlowski6132

07-31-06   very well put, i'd say. that's my viewpoint, although i st ...   Psychicanimal

08-01-06   Maineiac: after that last post, i will now regard everything ...   Zaikesman

08-01-06   Hey, it could happen. my cats lick the records clean for me. ...   Dougdeacon

08-01-06   Maineiac must live in stepford   Jaybo

08-15-06   Ok. sold the cdp. the clearaudio champ ii is on the way! nex ...   Pawlowski6132


  Post your response
Subject


Your response

No html, but you may use markup tags


Username
Members only

Password