AudiogoN
Search Buy Sell Learn MyPage
 Learn > Forums > Analog > 1033078770  Start New Thread | Log In | Bookmark This
  Why vinyl?
I understand the thoughts of a lot of you that digital is harsh and bright and has an edge. I know that analog has a warmer fuller sound, otherwise why would so many people put up with the inconvenience of records, cartridges, cleaners, tone-arm adjustments, etc. I used to be there. Of course all I had was a Garrard direct drive turntable. If the idea is to get as close as possible to the original source, why has not open-reel tape made a huge comeback. After all that's how most of the stuff was recorded in the first place. Very few were direct to disk recordings. Why would dragging a stylus through a groove be better than the original? There used to be a company out there called In-Synch that used the original masters and sold cassettes of them, dubbed at 1:1 ratio. I was the happiest person in the world when CD's came out and I could throw out my disk-washer and everything else that went with it, including the surface noise and the TICKS and POPS. Just something I've wondered about.
Elmuncy  (Threads | Answers | This Thread)

09-26-02
  Responses (1-60 of 60)
Click title to read one, or click date to read all below it.

09-26-02   I'm with you. i love cd's and the digital technology. once ...   Dweller

09-26-02   I was the happiest person in the world this week when i sold ...   Twl

09-26-02   I dabble in both worlds. i also have an sacd player. elmuncy ...   Jmcgrogan2

09-26-02   When cd's sound can match that of a good analog rig then i a ...   Thorty40

09-26-02   That's an interesting point about "why not tape?". ...   Kthomas

09-26-02   To answer your question from the viewpoint of someone who st ...   Viridian

09-27-02   Viridian, good post.   Judit

09-27-02   I have just begun a rexamination of my life (which of course ...   Gbeard

09-27-02   i also miss album covers. i was talking to a friend the oth ...   Blkadr

09-27-02   Viridian, the studio mastering speed is 15ips. at speed of ...   Marakanetz

09-27-02   I've tweaked my cd-based system to where (to my ear) there i ...   Danner

09-27-02   Hey marakanetz...15ips and 30ips are both used. it depends ...   Phild

09-27-02   Thanks for the kind words judit. marakenetz, i was speaking ...   Viridian

09-27-02   Blkadr ... you're right. sound quality aside, lps are much ...   Seandtaylor99

09-27-02   I belive there is a happy medium and both can co exist quit ...   Natalie

09-27-02   I have been into digital for the entire time i have really b ...   Tok20000

09-27-02   I've been collecting vinyl since the mid 60's so i predate d ...   Lugnut

09-27-02   For what it's worth, i find the regimen of having to disc do ...   Timwat

09-27-02   Why vinyl? why not. like lugnut i have albums that are 30 ...   hfloyd5@

09-27-02   I believe now is the best time to jump back to vinyl. why!? ...   Edle

09-27-02   The sonic differences: just what is it about vinyl’s ...   Thomasheisig

09-27-02   Nice analysis thomasheisig! kf   Tok20000

09-27-02   For a long time, i wouldn't buy a tt or records. everytime ...   Lakefrontroad

09-27-02   Just a couple of additional thoughts. when cd came out it wa ...   Blkadr

09-27-02   i read an article about 5-6 years ago where sony built the ...   Basement

09-28-02   Thomasheisig, you realise, of course, that film playback is ...   inpepinnovations@

09-29-02   Inpepinnovations, something more to say ? or is that all ? i ...   Thomasheisig

09-29-02   Come on, inpepinnovations -- that's 32 analogue frames/sec : ...   Gregm

09-29-02   Thomas & greg, i am just pointing out the dangers of using a ...   inpepinnovations@

01-19-03   I give up. you're right. i've just ordered a new, to me, tur ...   Elmuncy

01-20-03   Really bad analog to digital conversions is a good reason. s ...   Ntscdan

01-23-03   I was just browsing at the sf stereo yesterday and came acro ...   3chihuahuas

03-01-03   The ticks, pops and maintenance of vinyl are just not worth ...   boje@

03-02-03   Because it touches, moves and inspires every time. that's wh ...   Tuboo

03-04-03   I must chime in here as a long time cd listener and brand ne ...   Matt8268

03-04-03   I love the way the original question concerned open reel tap ...   Viridian

03-05-03: Albertporter
Viridian, perhaps because it is impossible to find new releases on open reel tape. Only two formats remain to discuss, I.E.: (from post originator).

"I understand the thoughts of a lot of you that digital is harsh and bright and has an edge. I know that analog has a warmer fuller sound"

Thus, the topic began with a statement of digital versus analog.

Albertporter  (System | Threads | Answers | This Thread)


03-05-03   No, albert, i can't read it the way that you do. the questio ...   Viridian

03-05-03   I have recently gotten back into vinyl after 15 years. all t ...   Bld63

03-05-03   Digital breaks up the unitary spatial perspective into plane ...   Asa

03-05-03   I know at least one person who still uses open reel as a mai ...   Nrchy

03-05-03   Asa, well said. i agree completely.   Unsound

03-06-03   Oh my god, unsound, we've met in the middle! i saw your post ...   Asa

03-06-03   I am eating peanuts, don't bother me! oh, you want some? ;-)   6chac

03-07-03   Hi william! yes, i can see that, like elmucy, that if ticks ...   Asa

03-11-03   I like vinyl for the "cheapness". just today i bo ...   Playtrim

03-11-03   No one loves vinyl more than me...but its about the music..n ...   jrd@

03-12-03   I agree with that too jrd, wholeheartedly. but it would be n ...   Asa

03-13-03   It is about two years ago, that i started experimenting with ...   Detlof

03-14-03   Heres my 2 cents worth 1st pops and clicks, pops are dirt an ...   Rockinroni

03-14-03   Nice post ron.   Asa

03-14-03   Thanks ron. you addressed the importance of quality and how ...   Albertporter

03-15-03   Ron points well made. it really is separating the forest fr ...   Gajgmusic

03-15-03   Very good points ron, in fact i sometimes tend to suspect, t ...   Detlof

04-11-03   With the utmost of respect i'll recount a recent experience. ...   domo@

04-11-03   Well spoken from there downunder! hear-hear! ps: you forgot ...   Detlof

04-11-03   Hello detlof, good to see you again along these shores. of c ...   Gregm

04-11-03   Pops and cracks ?? i hear nothing but music from my black an ...   Audio999

04-15-03   As many may already know there's a nice web page out there e ...   Agonanon

04-21-03   Sooo coool, domo.   Asa


  Post your response
Subject


Your response

No html, but you may use markup tags


Username
Members only

Password