AudiogoN
Search Buy Sell Learn MyPage
 Learn > Forums > Digital > 1335626029  Start New Thread | Log In | Bookmark This
  Any hope for SACD?
Is there any hope at all for transferring more music, especially classic popular music, to SACD?

I mean, so many audio companies are investing so much in R+D for the hardware, but, to me clearly, there is huge bang for the buck in having an SACD version of the recording.
For example, the recent Carole King Music SACD is incredible, with a totally natural image density and rock-solid soundstaging (qualities I hear in most SACDs of long-familiar albums). Is there no economic justification for this? You get so much for so little. I wish the audio companies would band together to fund this. It sure would make equipment demos sound better.

My little system at home with SACD trounced the quality of even the megabuck systems at the NY show a few weeks ago, including all the vinyl demos to my ears. (My EMM XDS1 helps, but my Sony 5400 on SACD is also quite fine.)

It just seems like such an incredible waste that SACD is dead or dying and nobody in the audiophile or larger music community is talking about this. Does everything have to suffer at the invisible hand of the profit motive? This is an artistic pursuit fundamentally, and you might as well always show all the paintings in the world behind blurry glass. It's a crime that, say, the Beatles aren't available in SACD or any HiRez format.
Rgs92  (Reviews | Threads | Answers | This Thread)

04-28-12
  Responses (1-34 of 34)
Click title to read one, or click date to read all below it.

04-28-12   Forget sacd. much to my regret the format is dead. you can t ...   Edorr

04-28-12   It's probably worth it for someone with a player like yours, ...   Chayro

04-29-12: Tomcy6
It depends on how well they sell. If Analogue Productions and MoFi make good money from their SACD efforts we'll see more of them. I don't see why they can't crank them out like they do in Japan. There has to be some DSD equipment sitting around unused.

Wish You Were Here seems to have sold a bunch but there are few albums that can sell like that one based on the promise of improved sound quality.

I don't think the Beatles will be reissued again. It's such a huge undertaking and I think the families may be satisfied that they have enough money after the last reissue.

Tomcy6  (Threads | Answers | This Thread)


04-29-12   Not until they release miles/blue on sacd. it has been long ...   Buconero117

04-29-12   Http://www.cdjapan.co.jp/detailview.html?key=sicp-10083 thi ...   Doggiehowser

04-29-12   Rgs92, there is a ton of classical on sacd, also downloadabl ...   Jfrech

04-29-12   To the op, i've been buying up dvda and sacds including some ...   Doggiehowser

04-29-12   Is there a reason sacd's can't be poped out on bluray?   Vicdamone

04-29-12   Everything good in audio has been or is being killed off by ...   Rok2id

04-29-12   Chayro, your answer is to buy a oppo 95 and have it modded w ...   Jwm

04-29-12   There are some audiophile labels which issue sacds on a regu ...   Mrtennis

04-29-12   Far from dead. check out the acoustic sounds website. as a ...   Pdn

04-30-12   @vicdamone, i don't believe dsd is a supported codec on blur ...   Doggiehowser

04-30-12   Buconero117, kinf of blue is in fact out on sacd.   Edorr

04-30-12   This issue is not sacd /dsd per se. blu ray audio can carry ...   Edorr

04-30-12   Of this you must be sure, he was dead as as a doornail.   Mechans

05-01-12   What are some options used to process downloadable mch high- ...   Vicdamone

05-01-12   I think some avrs do playback multichannel flac. i recall re ...   Doggiehowser

05-01-12   Search sacd on amazon and you will find 4,000+ sacds. some ...   Don_c55

05-01-12   Why would anyone want to buy a dead end... sacd is a closed ...   Davide256

05-01-12   Sacd has been out for a decade...so it had its chances...but ...   Phasecorrect

05-02-12   Because i find dsd still sounds better than hr pcm and a spu ...   Doggiehowser

05-08-12   I suspect that sacd was created partially to introduce forma ...   Kijanki

05-09-12   Looking back...as someone who was initially very enthusiasti ...   Phasecorrect

05-11-12   I was thinking that sacd was analogous to hdtv, but i guess ...   Rgs92

05-11-12   I think what phasecorrect is saying is that the new bd audio ...   Doggiehowser

05-11-12   The difference between encoded high rez pcm (which is what b ...   Edorr

05-11-12   I guess my point was is that the entire high-end audio manuf ...   Rgs92

05-11-12   And just to rant some more, the use of sacd really distances ...   Rgs92

05-12-12   I do have my share of hirez pcm stuff but when i compare my ...   Doggiehowser

05-12-12   I'd still much rather have a broadly available high rez form ...   Edorr

05-12-12   Give me a player like the cary 306 sacd professional version ...   Milpai

05-12-12   Doggiehowser: "because i find dsd still sounds better ...   Jfrech

05-13-12   I have in no particular order: bel canto cd2/dac3.5vbmkii, a ...   Doggiehowser


  Post your response
Subject


Your response

No html, but you may use markup tags


Username
Members only

Password