AudiogoN
Search Buy Sell Learn MyPage
 Learn > Forums > Digital > 1275247818  Start New Thread | Log In | Bookmark This

  Best Dac with USB input for $1,000 or less
So what is the current consenus out there now-a-days for the best dac with USB input for a grand or less.

I see a lot of favorable press for the MHDT Havana. Is this the one to beat?

Thank you for sharing your thoughts.
No_regrets  (System | Threads | Answers | This Thread)

05-30-10
  Responses (1-26 of 26)
Click title to read one, or click date to read all below it.

05-30-10   Imo, the havana is over rated.   Face

05-30-10: Jax2
With the Havana the other SPDIF options do sound better to my ears. I don't agree with the previous post - I think the Havana is a damn good DAC for the $, but I would not use the USB input. Use optical or single ended. If you must go USB I'd look at the asynchronous implementation by Wavelength, or options by Empirical to get zeros and ones off your box. Both are more expensive. I think the inexpensive USB/SPDIF conversion in DACs at that price point just don't sound that good to my ears. That said, the PS Audio DLIII in stock form and various forms of upgrade might be a good choice if you simply must go that route and want to stick to that budget. I have a stock one in my office system and use the optical input - I have compared and it does not give up much via USB as the Havana does. Not sure how it accomplishes that...perhaps better jitter reduction? On the used market a stock one is half your budget, while you can get a pretty pimped out version for $1k. No experience with the flashier versions. Good luck!
Jax2  (Reviews | Threads | Answers | This Thread)


05-31-10: Ejlif
The Havana with the Bel Canto USB link sounds absolutely awesome and beats anything I've heard up to 4000.00. There are other DACs that reveal more, show more imaging reverb trails blah blah blah but the Havana gets to the soul of the music and to me that is what counts. I hear more of all the audiophile things we talk about with other DACs but am always restless and find my mind wandering when I don't have the Havana in the system.
Ejlif  (System | Threads | Answers | This Thread)


05-31-10: Tgrisham
PS Audio DLIII is fantastic. Not overly detailed. It has a soul and presents the music as real, not digital. It has USB, optical and coaxial inputs, all of which are very good.
Tgrisham  (System | Reviews | Threads | Answers | This Thread)


05-31-10   Ejlif, do you believe your preference for the havana has to ...   Lewinskih01

05-31-10: Mb9061
No_Regrets - what is the rest of your setup like (i.e. solid state amps, etc.?). Are you looking for detail, or to corrale digital and its tendency towards being bright? Do you prefer upsampling? There's too many options to just throw out a general question.

The Havana is a great DAC. With a tube'd preamp, the right set of ICs and a good power cord it could be just what you're looking for. If the damn thing had a built in analog preamp I wouldn't have sold my Havana last year. My setup is all tube and on the warm side with a Rogue Stereo 90 and a pair of Living Voice speakers. I settled on the 2009 TADAC with built in preamp for now, but most of the dirty work is being done by an Empirical Audio Turbo-3 and some pricey digital cabling.

For under a grand with nothing upstream addressing the USB jitter, you'll have a tough time finding very clean sound. Probably Benchmark would be your best option since it's under $1k used and deals with USB fairly well. It's very detailed in sound though (I used to own one). The Havana doesn't sound very good via USB compared to a clean SPDIF fed to it via it's RCA input.

Solid state dacs sound very different from tubed. I've owned 3 solid state DACs (all over $1k on the used market) and two tubed DACs (both well UNDER $1k on the used market). I'd take the simple tube DACs every time if given a choice but it's all down to preference.

Mb9061  (Threads | Answers | This Thread)


05-31-10: Mb9061
Sorry, as the others have said, the Digilink III from PS Audio may do the trick too for USB under $1k, but some have reviewed it and compared it to the Benchmark DAC1 (analytical/detailed sound).

OK...I'll shut up now...

Mb9061  (Threads | Answers | This Thread)


05-31-10: Jax2
05-31-10: Mb9061
Sorry, as the others have said, the Digilink III from PS Audio may do the trick too for USB under $1k, but some have reviewed it and compared it to the Benchmark DAC1 (analytical/detailed sound).

I'm not a Benchmark fan and have listened pretty extensively to that DAC having owned a USB version and borrowed the previous version. I can tell you from my perspective I would have never thought to compare the DLIII with the Benchmark sound - they do not remind me of each other at all. I find the DLIII to be more natural sounding, not at all sterile or strident and very engaging. The Benchmark would always grate on me, especially in the upper frequencies...but overall it always sounded to me rather artificial and squeeky clean, and yes, sterile. I've heard it sound good in other systems at shows, but not in mine nor my friends. Anyway, I can't imagine what similarities it shares with the the DLIII in terms of sound qualities. Just my .02 cents.

Jax2  (Reviews | Threads | Answers | This Thread)


05-31-10   Decware zdac-1 ?? haven't heard this since it's just out si ...   Ngjockey

06-01-10   I don't know if it's the tube that is the thing that makes m ...   Ejlif

06-01-10   The benchmark does a very good job on usb as well as the spd ...   Pkubica

06-01-10   agreed. it is great value. of course it works best with ver ...   Shadorne

06-01-10: No_regrets
I've got a few different systems that it may grace from time to time, all of them are vacuum tube based. The system that it would spend the most time in is in my den. There are times when I like to listen to Pandora Internet radio from my laptop as background music. I was thinking of going USB into the Havana then into my tubed electronics which drive a pair of vintage Tannoy Monitor Golds in custom cabinets.

I thought that using the Havana or something simalar would maybe enhance the sound of the Pandora. I don't know if the laptop has any other outputs other than the USB.

It sounds like the PS Audio may be one worth looking into, providing it doesn't sound analytical, sterile, harsh, etc.

Thank you to all for your comments. I truly do appreciate them.

No_regrets  (System | Threads | Answers | This Thread)


06-02-10   The music hall 25.2 seems to get good press. even swapping o ...   Mjm1124

06-02-10   [agreed. it is great value. of course it works best with ver ...   Pkubica

06-02-10: Trianglezerius
My vote goes for the Tranquility Dac by dB Audio Labs. I just recently did a comparison in my system against the Ayre and PS Audio perfect wave. As good as the Ayres soundstage was the Tranquility's was better and had sustain and decay missing in digital.
Trianglezerius  (System | Reviews | Threads | Answers | This Thread)


06-02-10: Jax2
Tranquility DAC? I seem to recall a lengthy horn-tootin' post on that DAC over on AudioCircle - was that you on that trumpet as well? I haven't heard much else about it except [URL=forum.audiogonaudio+labs+tranquility+usb+dac]thisvery tranparent shill post[/URL] here on Agon. I have not found sustain and decay to be missing in digital. Did you find it to be missing in those other DACs you mention comparing it to?
Jax2  (Reviews | Threads | Answers | This Thread)


06-03-10   Hi jax that was my thread i started on ac. yes i did on the ...   Trianglezerius

06-04-10   sorry, i don't think i understand you. sustain and decay ar ...   Jax2

06-04-10: Dracule1
I was at the Lone Star Audiofest last month and listened to the Tranquility DAC. At the RMAF last year, I listened to the PS Audio Perfect Wave DAC. The PS group had better electronics and speakers with their DAC than dB Audio Labs did. I found the Tranquility more natural sounding. But the DACs were in different systems and at different times, so you have take my comments with a grain of salt. And yes as the above poster stated, the Tranquility does the natural decay of instruments better than any I have heard. I'm glad I got one for myself.

No_Regrets, if you can splurge an extra $300 ($1300 if you are an Audio Circle member, just sign up), I think this DAC will sound more natural and satisfying than anything mentioned on this thread. BTW, I have heard the ultra expensive dCS, Play Back Designs, and Meitners. In all honesty, I enjoyed the Tranquility more. But again, these were not side side comparisons.

FYATHYRIO...

Dracule1  (Reviews | Threads | Answers | This Thread)


06-22-10   Havana is overrated imo too id get a peachtree decco2 or no ...   Mrkoven

06-24-10   the havana *is* the one to beat in the sub 1k price range. ...   Notec

06-24-10   The new w4s dac 1. all sub $1k dac's must bow before it ;-)   Erikminer

06-25-10   I agree with erik, i'd check out the dac-1.   Face

08-29-10   Rega will have one out in the fall. i'll bet it will sound ...   Realhifi

11-02-10   Overrated??? i own the $5,000 weiss minerva. my friends ow ...   Devilboy


  Post your response
Subject


Your response

No html, but you may use markup tags


Username
Members only

Password