Click title to read one, or click date to read all below it.
05-15-11
I was at the 12:00 demo also. i actually preferred the q3 d ... Peterayer
05-15-11
I too attend the q3 demo. it was well done and the speakers ... Jerry_gt3rs
05-15-11
I was at the 2:00 pm q3 demo. the set up was superb as woul ... Jimf
05-15-11
Had the date circled but had to cancel in the last minute. ... Knghifi
05-15-11
Goodwin's has one of the best showrooms in the world, and so ... Rtn1
05-15-11
Are the q3 drivers the same for the q1? anybody know the co ... Lapierre
05-15-11
"anybody know the cost of the q1?" or the boulder ... Lokie
05-16-11
I forgot about that demo...damn. i did get my own demo a few ... Wolf_garcia
05-16-11
The q1 retails for $59 or 60k. i don't know the price of th ... Peterayer
05-16-11
Sorry, i meant to say the q5, not the q1. the q1 will retai ... Peterayer
05-16-11
Goodwin's website shows the 1000 watt bolder 2050 monos with ... Kana813
06-06-11
Several months ago, when the prototype of the q3 came out, m ... Eps
06-14-11
Sounds great think i might want one. Ebm
06-15-11
Just taken delivery of one of the first customer pairs of q3 ... Folkfreak
06-15-11
Folk- what electronics are you using? Darkstar01
06-15-11
Congratulations ...... really .... folkfreak Ciro71
06-15-11
06-15-11: folkfreak for example sandy denny was not a tall o ... Audiofeil
06-16-11
Thanks for the interest in terms of amps they are vtl mb-45 ... Folkfreak
06-16-11
interesting. could a petite person have a petite voice, and ... Jdoris
06-16-11
"does a mandolin sound "smaller" than a doubl ... Usermanual
06-16-11
06-16-11: jdoris could a petite person have a petite voice d ... Audiofeil
06-16-11
I think ronstadt does in fact have a small person's voice; i ... Jdoris
06-16-11
Billy... bizniz must be good .. lol.. :) slam dunk that . ... Weseixas
06-16-11
What about mike tyson? in his prime, the baddest man on ear ... Knghifi
06-16-11
Ronstadt, from a musicians point of view, had/has what is ge ... Wolf_garcia
06-16-11
I understand folkfreak's comments about scale the same way w ... Peterayer
06-16-11
Calm down sports fans. if you re-read my posts, this is my ... Audiofeil
06-17-11
Did i mention ronstadt's head...huge...like a gigantic mexic ... Wolf_garcia
06-17-11
I would tend to agree with audiofeil and peterayer´s observa ... Tubegroover
06-17-11: Martykl
Does anyone seriously think that Tyson,Neville, and Barbra provide "irrefutable" evidence that there's NO (positive) correlation between body size and certain characteristics of a person's voice (pitch/power)?
It is certainly anecdotal evidence against a positive correlation, while ...say... the long, historical parade of "plus sized" professional sopranos is anecdotal evidence of a positive correlation (as to power, at least).
I can't say with any certainty, but I'd suspect from my own anecdotal experience that a statistical analysis would bear out John's point. (That there is a positive correlation.) I'd also guess that John's reasoning is probably correct - chest volume, certain muscle mass, and vocal chord length (probably among a whole bunch of other things) are probably highly correlated with pitch and/or power. Those physical characteristics, themselves, are also likely to be highly (tho not perfectly) correlated with body size - accounting both for the correlation AND for the exceptions noted above.
That is just a guess. The real point is that no one has posted any "irrefutable" evidence to this thread one way or the other.
I can say with certainly that any positive correlation (if it exists) is not perfect. I can also say with certainty that Bill's assertion is not "irrefutable". It is an overstatement. (surprise.)
Marty
BTW, I also agree that, in all likelihood, none of this has anything to do with the OP's original point.
Martykl (Reviews | Threads | Answers | This Thread)
06-17-11
Big joe turner (6'2"/300 lbs.): http://www.youtube.com ... Jdoris
06-17-11
With respect to the discussion of voice reproduction, i thin ... Almarg
06-17-11
John, "don't singers and guitars both have bodies?&quo ... Martykl
06-17-11
One comment about speakers portraying "the size" o ... Maril555
06-17-11
As a singer, i am now learning to perform test tones in case ... Wolf_garcia
06-17-11
To the op: i was at the goodwin's demo. it was a wonderful ... Peterayer
06-17-11
Professional singers when unamplified and in large halls wil ... Rtn1
06-17-11
Having triggered what seems to have been a very interesting ... Folkfreak
06-17-11
Whow think ill get 2 pairs. Ebm
06-18-11
Hmmm, interesting point about voice and scale of singers. un ... Suteetat
06-30-11
Finally i got to hear q3. however, the speakers only arrived ... Suteetat
06-30-11
Magico does have a weird issue with these new models seeming ... Wolf_garcia
06-30-11
I think the q3 retails for $34,000, substantially less than ... Peterayer
06-30-11
Yes, q3 cost more than the v3 but the improve in performance ... Suteetat
07-01-11
All the old speakers are suddenly no good hello lets wake up ... Ebm
07-01-11
I was referring to the q5 vs. the m5 price (oops)...and for ... Wolf_garcia
07-01-11
Ebm, i am not sure what you are upset about? i assume that i ... Suteetat
07-01-11
Nothing like a good room and good setup to make a good syste ... Mapman
07-01-11
I agree q3 must sound great i have no place to hear it in ny ... Ebm
07-01-11
I humbly submit that i think ebm was being sarcastic in his ... Peterayer
|
|
