AudiogoN
Search Buy Sell Learn MyPage
 Learn > Forums > Speakers > 1274537281  Start New Thread | Log In | Bookmark This
  Why not horns?
I've owned a lot of speakers over the years but I have never experienced anything like the midrange reproduction from my horns. With a frequency response of 300 Hz. up to 14 Khz. from a single distortionless driver, it seems like a no-brainer that everyone would want this performance. Why don't you use horns?
Macrojack  (Reviews | Threads | Answers | This Thread)

05-22-10
  Responses (51-100 of 892)
Click title to read one, or click date to read all below it.

05-23-10   Funny... if i am not mistaken, not one person, has really ...   Bjpd57a1

05-23-10: Csmgolf
I do not have extensive experience with horns, but I do have some. I had heard several sets of horns and found them to be ok, but not great. The last three years I have gone to the Audiokarma show in Detroit and listened to every speaker I could. I paid particular attention to the horns. Granted, many of the rooms were not optimal. However, the room for Classic Audio Reproductions had people that should have known how to set them up. Each year they had speaker systems of 20k and higher with the set this year at 36k. The mids and treble were very nice but the bass was just plain bad. There was a resonance in the upper bass that made them not listenable for me. I am not sure what was causing it, but it sure sounded like a lively cabinet. I could not believe that a speaker of that price was producing it. Every year I have left their room thinking that if this is the best that horns have to offer, I could not do it. It certainly was not because of cheap electronics on any occasion.
Despite all of that, I purchased a new pair of the Emerald Physics CS2's. The decision was based partly on buzz the product had been receiving and partly because I really like open baffle bass. I burned them in for about 500 hours. At that time I was using a Classe CP60 pre, an Upgrade Company modified Denon 3910. Amplification was a pair of Aragon Palladium 2 monos on the bass section and a Pass Aleph 30 on the tweeter. Ridge Street Audio cables were used through out. I could never warm up to the sound of them. There was a resonance in the mids that would occur that sounded like talking thru a megaphone. It did not happen all of the time, but it was enough to be musically distracting and I found it to be unacceptable. Another thing I did not like about them was that the soundstage was 2 dimensional. That could have been due to my set up, but they were set up per manufaturer instructions even including phone conversations with Clayton Shaw. The 2 dimensional aspect also contributed to the fact that they sounded like a very good PA system, but not what I am looking for when I listen at home. I did listen to the CS3's at AK fest 2009 and found them to be an improvement, but not enough for me to buy them. With my somewhat limited experience, it will take some major convincing to get me to go down that path again.

Csmgolf  (System | Threads | Answers | This Thread)


05-23-10   There is this device called a, "sub-woofer" it ...   Bjpd57a1

05-24-10   I love horn speakers, and agree with just about everything s ...   Learsfool

05-24-10   There is this device called a, "sub-woofer" it ...   Csmgolf

05-24-10   Herman... sounding like trumpets is a quite precise descript ...   Eldartford

05-24-10   Csm, if you were trying to address my issue re: "hybri ...   Martykl

05-24-10   Csmgolf has provided a personal account of an honest attempt ...   Macrojack

05-24-10   Dartford, i accept your assessment of what you heard. i am c ...   Herman

05-24-10   Lots of personal bias, limited experience, a passing listen ...   Johnk

05-24-10   Marty, my comments were not addressing your post, but thanks ...   Csmgolf

05-24-10   Johnk, looking at your system it raises an interesting quest ...   Herman

05-24-10   Its a good question. also lots of good answers that seem to ...   Mapman

05-24-10   Take some time to examine this design. http://www.techfx.u ...   Macrojack

05-24-10   horns are great. they are the best solution for many applic ...   Shadorne

05-24-10   Shadorne, classic audio loudspeakers makes a horn that cross ...   Atmasphere

05-24-10   They sound like a pa system. go figger.   Markws

05-24-10   I have found this to be a very educational thread. well don ...   Onhwy61

05-24-10   Ralph, i would agree - they are at their very best in farf ...   Shadorne

05-24-10   "why don't you use horns?" well you asked, so i'm ...   Apollo66

05-24-10   Proselytizing? me? well, perhaps i am. but i'm not twisting ...   Macrojack

05-24-10   Generalizations about horn systems tend to short-change mode ...   Audiokinesis

05-24-10   There is a saying in zen, if you are off by an inch, you a ...   Weisselk

05-25-10   The above two posts come from two of the leading lights in a ...   Macrojack

05-25-10   I just read my above post and discovered some very poor word ...   Macrojack

05-25-10   You can have my horns when you pry my cold, dead hands off o ...   Dan_ed

05-25-10   Let's not be adversarial about this. any speaker is a legiti ...   Macrojack

05-25-10   Herman... my thoughts are along the lines cited by apollo66. ...   Eldartford

05-25-10   "to cover the full spectrum... i can't stand horns. por ...   Mapman

05-25-10   Wow what responses;get out the bullet proof vests.   Rleff

05-25-10   Eldartford, and appollo66, i remember back in the early 90s ...   Atmasphere

05-25-10   Watch out ralph i think there could be a few daggers coming ...   Rleff

05-25-10   Atmasphere:okay...very well put. big thumbs up. mapman: new ...   Bjpd57a1

05-25-10   Atmasphere, i could not have put it better myself. i spent ...   Chadeffect

05-25-10   Many people today are unable to differentiate between what t ...   Macrojack

05-26-10   Horns are music and instrument selective. no speakers can r ...   Orpheus10

05-26-10   "horns have unexploited potential. lets get busy harves ...   Lokie

05-26-10   Herman, the tweeters a horn fostex t500amk2 , mids horn, mid ...   Johnk

05-26-10   Horns were the dominant speaker technology for many years, p ...   Unsound

05-26-10   Horns can be designed to work great at less than 10ft sittin ...   Johnk

05-26-10   Lots of impressive horn setups on this site. this may be th ...   Mapman

05-26-10   Johnk - since you know what you are talking about, it would ...   Macrojack

05-26-10   Great questions. john and ralph are way ahead of me with hor ...   Dan_ed

05-26-10   As herman pointed out back loaded horns really are not horns ...   Johnk

05-26-10   Mapman, that system looks impressive but that big white &quo ...   Herman

05-26-10   I was hoping to solicit input from people who know and under ...   Macrojack

05-26-10   Ah, there is another interesting issue with horns. the quest ...   Dan_ed

05-26-10   "the throat may need to be like 35 feet long" i c ...   Mapman

05-26-10   Dan - i can hardly fault you for being an analogue purist bu ...   Macrojack

05-26-10   "do you admire his system or not?" yes. i just t ...   Mapman


< Prev 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 >> Next >

  Post your response
Subject


Your response

No html, but you may use markup tags


Username
Members only

Password