AudiogoN
Search Buy Sell Learn MyPage
 Learn > Forums > Speakers > 1258843373  Start New Thread | Log In | Bookmark This

  frequency response - B&W vs. Monitor Audio
I currently have a pair of B&W 685s and I am considering replacing them with a pair of Monitor Audio BR2s. The MAs freq resp gets down to 42Hz; the B&Ws only get down to 49Hz. Is this an audible difference? I would be getting the MAs through a friend who has access to wholesale prices and I will not be able to audition the MAs.
2nd issue - I am considering high-passing my bookshelfs through an active crossover in a powered sub. This will cut out frequencies below 80Hz before the signal gets to the amp and the bookshelfs. If I do this, does it matter if I upgrade to the MAs? Their high end is 30kHz, the B&Ws high end is only 22kHz. Thanks.
Realremo  (System | Threads | Answers | This Thread)

11-21-09
  Responses (1-21 of 21)
Click title to read one, or click date to read all below it.

11-21-09   If you have access to wholesale prices you owe it to yoursel ...   Surferjoe

11-22-09   "the mas freq resp gets down to 42hz; the b&ws only get ...   Acoustat6

11-22-09   Bob says...those are only numbers, its how they sound that c ...   Tpreaves

11-22-09   Also, regarding the high end frequencies, very few folks can ...   Mtrot

11-22-09   Don't forget the room and setup! also, when it comes to lf e ...   Magfan

11-22-09: Stanwal
Two points: everyone is right, frequency response, in and of itself tells little about the "sound" of the speaker. Second, response above and below what we can "hear" influences out perception of the sound that is audible to us. I find that my subs make music sound more realistic even when there is supposedly no content present in the range they cover. The human perception system is fascinatingly complex and not yet completely understood. There was a recent experiment in which it appears that our sensitivity to ultra high frequency sound was not through our ears but through the body in some way. This sounds weird and it is but when the body was blocked from the sound and the ears left exposed the sound could not be perceived; when the ears were blocked and the body left exposed it could. As Haldane said'"The world is not stranger than we imagine, it is stranger than we can imagine".
Stanwal  (System | Reviews | Threads | Answers | This Thread)


11-22-09   The lowest note on a standard piano is a1 @27.5hz, and if yo ...   Gawdbless

11-22-09   The 'demo' disc that came with my sub has an organ track wit ...   Magfan

11-22-09   Magfan you are indeed correct, the bosendorfer mental amount ...   Gawdbless

11-23-09: Realremo
Thanks for all the posts, very interesting. My amp is a 15 year old Yamaha RX-485, I'm also running a 15 year old Yamaha CDP. I cannot decide if I want to upgrade the speakers or the electronics! Budget is about $1600.
No one has mentioned anything about high-passing the B&Ws, would that help? I'm afraid it would hurt the imaging of the sound, too much coming from the sub in the corner.
Even if I upgrade the speakers, I will still be missing that extra low-end oomph; I think I need a sub woofer.
I will probably purchase a <$1000 integrated and mate it with a sub woofer. The room is small, like 14x12x8. Possible combos include Cambridge Audio 650 + SVS PB10, or an NAD C326 with a Velodyne DEQ-10R. NAD to sub connections are quirky. The CA has A/B switching, so I can do a high-level connect to the sub.

Realremo  (System | Threads | Answers | This Thread)


11-23-09   If you're getting a powered sub, then it does not matter wha ...   Dylanhenry

11-24-09   The ma br line is their entry line and imo inferior to the b ...   Jaxwired

11-24-09   Jaxwired your point is well taken regarding the br2s, and if ...   Realremo

11-24-09   If you high-pass the monitors, there's no reason to consider ...   Bob_reynolds

11-24-09   Sorry, i just read your last post. if you're heading for a s ...   Bob_reynolds

11-24-09   Dylanhenry-, there must be a reason why speakers (tweeters) ...   Gawdbless

11-24-09   I have to agree with the guy who said ma br is inferior to b ...   Koven

11-25-09   Gawdbless, yes there is a reason why tweeters can perform be ...   Dylanhenry

11-25-09   Bob_reynolds, thanks again for another interesting equipment ...   Realremo

05-27-11: Realremo
THREAD UPDATE:
I have all new electronics in the listening room, and I am currently "borrowing" the 685s from my upstairs home theater. I want the 685s back up there, so I am now considering Monitor Audio BX5s, PSB T45-T55...listening room now features a newer Denon changer, the Halo P3, and a 200wpc Rotel amp...

Realremo  (System | Threads | Answers | This Thread)


05-08-12   Thread update: went with the ma bx5s and i'm very happy with ...   Realremo


  Post your response
Subject


Your response

No html, but you may use markup tags


Username
Members only

Password