AudiogoN
Search Buy Sell Learn MyPage
 Learn > Forums > Speakers > 1218759698  Start New Thread | Log In | Bookmark This
  Best all around speakers
Just curious what people think around here for best all around speakers for wide variety of musical genres and amplifications needs (tubes and solid state). Not everybody listen exclusively to Diana Krall and Norah Jones and/or acoustical jazz or classical music. Some of us like to listen to a wide variety of music (from rock and roll to bluegrass to blues to you name it) and don't feel the need or want to have a differet speaker for each genre of music. Seems to me many speaker designers have a very narrow taste in music, which unfortunately doesn't reflect what most people listen to, which I think is one of the reasons why many speakers end up disappointing quite a number of listeners.
Cleaneduphippy  (Threads | Answers | This Thread)

08-14-08
  Responses (1-72 of 72)
Click title to read one, or click date to read all below it.

08-14-08   Nice post.   Rgs92

08-14-08   I'm coming to a tentative conclusion that you might have to ...   Eweedhome

08-15-08   Atc are very precise and therefore play a wide variety of ge ...   Bongofury

08-15-08   Go to the montana audio site and check it out   Wwshull

08-15-08   I just bought a pair of german physiks carbon mkiv's. stu ...   Starcon

08-15-08   Cleaneduhippy, don't you know already?there is a category o ...   Fafafion

08-15-08   I second fafafion and bongofury but with a caveat - there re ...   Shadorne

08-15-08   Imho, for the time being at least, the notion that the best ...   Unsound

08-15-08   I've never understood trying to match speakers to particular ...   Dcstep

08-15-08   I prefer the strategy of matching amp to speakers rather tha ...   Mapman

08-15-08   I'll give a plug for sp technology speakers. good enough tha ...   Spenceroo

08-15-08   the picture is rather less black and white than you paint. ...   Shadorne

08-15-08   "some audiophiles have several systems that are suited ...   Mapman

08-15-08   Agree with shadorne, dunlavy (and duntech's classic series) ...   Rcprince

08-15-08   I'm really not sure either there is one speaker that can sou ...   Mapman

08-15-08   Bang for the buck..used dunlavy/duntech/hales   Jaybo

08-15-08   Agree with shadhorne completely. i have never heard a speak ...   Eweedhome

08-15-08   "that's because source material is recorded and mastere ...   Mapman

08-15-08   sure there are many other speakers that handle everything e ...   Shadorne

08-15-08   So isn't the fact of the matter then that there are many spe ...   Mapman

08-15-08   i'd fully agree with "there are many speakers out ther ...   Shadorne

08-15-08   Mapman, you're quite right, an awful lot of this is personal ...   Eweedhome

08-15-08   I disagree with many audio designers have a narrow taste in ...   Johnk

08-15-08   I agree that most speaker manufacturers tailor the speaker t ...   Musicnoise

08-15-08   Its almost like investing.....maybe never put all your eggs ...   Mapman

08-16-08   08-15-08: musicnoise said: "... the amount of distorti ...   Dcstep

08-15-08   I hate to think you're right, mapman, but i can sure think o ...   Eweedhome

08-16-08   This is such a subjective hobby, i really got into this hobb ...   Macdadtexas

08-16-08   It's subjective as macdadtexas points out. let me add it's a ...   Timrhu

08-16-08   Dcstep: you misconstrued the content of my post by inserting ...   Musicnoise

08-16-08   Timrhu, the room is one of the biggest factors for sure. m ...   Mapman

08-16-08   Good and lively discussion here, glad i started this thread, ...   Cleaneduphippy

08-16-08   Musicnoise, what you meant to say in your quoted text is mud ...   Dcstep

08-16-08   There is no ambiguity in the text of the post to which you i ...   Musicnoise

08-16-08   Musicnoise, i never said anything about live performance, so ...   Dcstep

08-16-08   this gets my vote for one of the wisest statements i have s ...   Shadorne

08-16-08   Dcstep: actually your phrase was "how can adding disto ...   Musicnoise

08-16-08   Go ahead, extract whatever you want out of context, the fact ...   Dcstep

08-16-08   I simply see no reason to accept an obvious misconstruction ...   Musicnoise

08-17-08   Lets look at the issue from a different perspective. the fi ...   Mrtennis

08-17-08   Here's another idea: a speaker which is compatible with man ...   Mrtennis

08-17-08   Mrtennis, well said. listening to radiohead "ok comput ...   Timrhu

08-17-08   " if you can listen to any recording , even one of poor ...   Calldr

08-17-08   Calldr said: "a speaker that will not let you hear a b ...   Dcstep

08-17-08: Eweedhome
"A speaker that will not let you hear a bad recording is a poor investment."

It's all a question of degree. I've had systems in my house on which about 10% of the CDs I played sounded great. The rest ranged from tolerable to "run screaming from the room" intolerable. Some would have considered those systems to be wonderfully accurate. From my point of view, they stank. And they're gone from my house, and I am thrilled.

The system I've built now will certainly let me know if I'm dealing with problematic source material. (And I think it is much more appropriate to call it "problem source material" than "a bad recording". What sounds "bad" on one system may well have sounded great to the recording engineer as he was playing it back perhaps as long as 30-40 years ago.) But it is rarely "in your face" about it. I can usually hear the music beyond the sonic problems. That, to me, is a sign of a very well designed system/speakers/whatever.

When I audition equipment at a dealer's, I always take some CDs to play that have problematic sound (in addition to some that sound great on almost anything). That way, I hear the strengths of the equipment, but I am also well aware of whatever fatigue factor exists in the equipment.

A system that is fatiguing to listen to is pretty darn worthless, seems to me. And it is hugely fatiguing to be regularly reminded of all the flaws in the source material you want to hear.

Eweedhome  (System | Threads | Answers | This Thread)


08-17-08   Eweedhome, what's your digital source? that's often the real ...   Dcstep

08-17-08   You know, i was always pleased with the way some speakers i ...   Rgs92

08-17-08   I think the issue here is : what is the virtue in suffering ...   Mrtennis

08-17-08   mrt - you are missing the whole point of this hobby. frustr ...   Shadorne

08-17-08   I with mrt, if you suffering, then get another hobby. music ...   Dcstep

08-17-08   I really like my vsa vr-7s - they play music. period. alth ...   Fplanner2000

08-18-08   As i said in a different thread, by far the best type of mus ...   Learsfool

08-18-08   My vote is for a design incorporating open baffel and wavegu ...   Consttraveler

08-18-08   To expand on learsfool's theme, any one of the recent sacds ...   Dcstep

08-18-08   these were monitored and mixed using quad esl 63's. these s ...   Shadorne

08-18-08   That was mastering really, wasn't it? no doubt it was in a p ...   Dcstep

08-18-08   Why is it necessary to expose one's ears to 100db in a room ...   Mrtennis

08-18-08   you hear more detail and it is realistic/exciting/fun/envel ...   Shadorne

08-18-08   No amp,preamp or speakers can replace the most important of ...   Mrjstark

08-18-08   If you listen at average levels of 85 to 87db, which is what ...   Dcstep

08-18-08   Dcstep - to your question about my digital sources: as i ma ...   Eweedhome

08-18-08   Eweedhome asked: "you have any suggestions?" pla ...   Dcstep

08-19-08   The previous discussion about speakers playing at high volum ...   Timrhu

08-19-08   Timrhu said: "when looking for speakers i look for a o ...   Dcstep

08-19-08   Consttraveler [the open baffel dipole design takes the room ...   Johnk

08-19-08   yes a drum set is insane! most brass instruments are insane ...   Shadorne

08-19-08   I have to imagine that a large speaker with multiple drivers ...   Pubul57

08-19-08   To shadorne's point, last saturday i listened to mahler's 1s ...   Dcstep

08-19-08   Is compression much more common in pop/rock? it seems like i ...   Pubul57

08-19-08   Pubul57 said: "is compression much more common in pop/ ...   Dcstep

08-20-08   Johnk: you are correct, i miss-spoke. the open baffel di-po ...   Consttraveler

09-06-08   I own hansen prince speakers. they are the best speakers i'v ...   Arthurp


  Post your response
Subject


Your response

No html, but you may use markup tags


Username
Members only

Password