AudiogoN
Search Buy Sell Learn MyPage
 Learn > Forums > Speakers > 1183441826  Start New Thread | Log In | Bookmark This
  Horns vs Ribbons vs Dyanamic
Something I've been interested in: could you shed some light on the pros and cons, as well as technical info, of different types of speakers? These are the kinds I know about, are there others?

Horns
Ribbons
Planar
Dynamic
Electrostatic (????)

Thanks
Ledhed2222  (Threads | Answers | This Thread)

07-03-07
  Responses (1-44 of 44)
Click title to read one, or click date to read all below it.

07-03-07   Horns - can be shrill if not done properly dynamic high out ...   Audiotomb

07-03-07   Just buy speakers you like the sound of, and don't fret over ...   Jaybo

07-03-07   Audiotomb made a good start, horns - tendency to honk/shril ...   Shadorne

07-03-07   A lot depends on your amp. planers and other panels suck up ...   Elevick

07-03-07   There are good examples of all these designs, past...and pre ...   Sogood51

07-03-07   For heaven sake, i would've thought by now everyone had this ...   Nsgarch

07-03-07   "these are almost never used in pro audio - so that tel ...   Snofun3

07-03-07   Ah thanks nsgarch. i didn't realize these things! several ...   Ledhed2222

07-03-07   i was thinking of things like 1) they are very difficult t ...   Shadorne

07-03-07   My ribbons are wonderful. no "reverberation" or & ...   Geojap

07-03-07   Planar - quick fast detailed, large projection only trade of ...   Chadnliz

07-03-07   Dynamic drivers = a driver where a coil -that carries the au ...   6bq5

07-03-07   well i am not sure what design you have. there always seem ...   Shadorne

07-03-07   I'm a bit partial at the moment to ribbons. i very recently ...   Stehno

07-03-07   while my current speakers dont have cone or dynamic midrang ...   Chadnliz

07-03-07   Stehno, what type of speakers are you using now with ribbon ...   Mr_bill

07-03-07: Shadorne
There is a substantial improvement in the mid and higher frequencies.

Yes that is the typical manifestation from the additional ambience or reverberation. The room is excited more in the mid range and treble than regular box speakers. (Basically an anechoic calibrated ribbon will have about 3 to 6 db boost in the mid and high frequencies when placed in a room and compared to a box speaker.) The fact that many popular selling box speakers are tweaked upwards in the treble and bass response (helps sell) means that the planar or ribbon will be a revelation (hear things you never heard before) to most people not used to a proper balanced mid range.... you can blame most popular box speaker manufacturers for this....big bass and treble sizzle sells but at the expense of the mid range!!

Shadorne  (System | Reviews | Threads | Answers | This Thread)


07-03-07   I am somewhat incredulous with regard to dome tweeters being ...   Mechans

07-04-07   First of all, there are exceptions to any generality put for ...   Audiokinesis

07-03-07   Very interesting responses. bill, the new speakers are lega ...   Stehno

07-03-07   In my experience, horns can make a dramatic first impression ...   Eldartford

07-03-07   6bq5, "electrostatics are at the other end, with a max ...   Curriemt11

07-04-07   Hi dr mechams says, "i grew up on horns still enjoy tem ...   Acoustat6

07-04-07   I have found that from around 65hz, and below...cones are ki ...   Sogood51

07-04-07   i see that "elementary" was either too much for y ...   Shadorne

07-04-07   What about line arrays? like horns (and sealed versus ported ...   Jb0194

07-04-07   Stehno...no offense, but test discs by their very nature, on ...   Jaybo

07-04-07   They all tend to push air. i think there was somthing called ...   Gregadd

07-04-07   Jaybo, our so-called 'test' cd was a natalie merchant cd. b ...   Stehno

07-05-07   Stehno wrote, "at ces 2008 we must have evaluated about ...   Chadnliz

07-05-07   stehno, no problem. peace. if you don't mind checking a ne ...   Shadorne

07-05-07   Jb0194: line arrays affect sound dispersion patterns. they r ...   Ngjockey

07-06-07   Come on give up on the honking horns the only horn i heard h ...   Johnk

07-06-07   would you feel this way about reproducing specifically stri ...   Aktchi

07-06-07   Yes, aktchi, modern properly designed & set up horns can hav ...   Triode

07-07-07   99.9% of all prerecorded music was(and is)made to sound like ...   Jaybo

07-07-07   Jaybo, who ever told you that all prerecorded music was(and ...   Stehno

07-07-07   Damn it jaybo, we're only audiogoners here not trekkies! we ...   Shadorne

07-08-07   No engineer or producer, other than one for audiophile label ...   Jaybo

07-08-07   Amazing.   Stehno

07-08-07   Yes i would.   Johnk

07-09-07   Audiokinesis, the single driver dynamic speaker that you me ...   Ledhed2222

07-14-07   Hey aktchi, just go listen to a good pair of horns. you mayb ...   Gawdbless

07-15-07   Hi ledhed, sorry this reply is so late - i just now checke ...   Audiokinesis


  Post your response
Subject


Your response

No html, but you may use markup tags


Username
Members only

Password