AudiogoN
Search Buy Sell Learn MyPage
 Learn > Forums > Home Theater > 1234213589  Start New Thread | Log In | Bookmark This
  Is there a consensus as to blu ray sound quality?
I have no doubt missed it...as it's probably been discussed ad nauseum on these electronic pages, but I still wonder...is there a consensus of the sound quality differential between regular players and the new blu ray?
Of course the video qualities and disc qualities are apparently much upgraded into the blu ray tech, but does this mean the sound is as consistently better? Has anyone played one of Winston Ma's incredible FIM remakes on a blu ray, if so tell us about what you're hearing.
Also, am wondering if any of the CD mfgrs are planning audiophile versions of blu ray??
Lrsky  (Threads | Answers | This Thread)

02-09-09
  Responses (1-51 of 51)
Click title to read one, or click date to read all below it.

02-09-09   As far as movies go, the new uncompressed audio tracks on bl ...   Kennyt

02-09-09   Developmenti? :-) i gotta admit, though, that it never ent ...   Kr4

02-09-09   Kenny, i've been out of the digital loop, so you'll have to ...   Lrsky

02-09-09   Kr4, yea the processing is the same, but the claim to fame i ...   Lrsky

02-09-09   Lrsky, i now understand what you were asking, do any blu-ra ...   Kennyt

02-09-09   The question was (is) are they better at audio playback, bet ...   Lrsky

02-10-09   Yes - i have seen a few audio titles published in bd (bluray ...   Ckorody

02-10-09   Only blu ray and hd-dvd (bye-bye) are encoded with lossless ...   Mmarvin19

02-10-09   naturally i'm no insider on the subject of high def video d ...   Blindjim

02-10-09   The blu-ray hd lossless formats are excellent but there are ...   Kr4

02-10-09   Arthur salvatore from the audio critique talks about the pos ...   Schipo

02-10-09: Lrsky
OK,
Maybe this whole concept of blu-ray has taken the debate into liscencing, and hardware dead ends. My questions are of a more fundamental nature.
1) Would employing a Blue Laser as opposed to a red one, which is to say, a laser which offers a shorter wave length of light, therefore can track the pits and such in a cd/dvd storage unit, more adroitly--is this laser an option for reading current red book cds? I KNOW it will read them--the overarching question is...does it when used, compared to a typical cd player SOUND better?
Is there hope that the typical audiophile out there can buy a $399 blue ray, and end up with sound quality which is better than even the very expensive (red laser) cd players which are audiophile grade?

Again, and I know this is getting tedious...years ago, everyone in the industry talked about the 'blue laser' and how the shorter wavelength would allow it to give a better read, with the assumed accomanying, more information for the processor to work with. Now that we have the blu-ray, is it a viable step up from a typical player sonically?
Surely someone has tried this comparison.
Also, any manufacturers talking about an audiophile version of blu ray...not for the extras on discs and such, but just improved sound?

Lrsky  (Threads | Answers | This Thread)


02-10-09   In my opinion, no, because of the blu-ray format itself. the ...   Rakuennow

02-10-09   "is there hope that the typical audiophile out there ca ...   Kijanki

02-10-09   Thanks kijanki, but i am aware of the breadth of variables w ...   Lrsky

02-10-09   All other things being equal, which is always a big assumpti ...   Markphd

02-10-09   Mark, i think in this example, we should make the general a ...   Lrsky

02-10-09   Lrsky - redbook is fixed at 16 bit and the only thing that b ...   Kijanki

02-10-09   Regarding your assumption that more is better: this further ...   Markphd

02-10-09   Thanks mark, and kijank, (and everyone) let me give one more ...   Lrsky

02-10-09   Lrsky - you assume that picture that you scan has unlimited ...   Kijanki

02-10-09   So, we're reading every last bit of information that exists ...   Lrsky

02-10-09   That's what i think. if error correction works and there is ...   Kijanki

02-10-09   Thanks, kijanki, so, in talking to some of the digital 'mast ...   Lrsky

02-10-09   Lrsky - better laser might provide better results with less ...   Kijanki

02-11-09   One could say that digital recreation is not analogous to th ...   Lrsky

02-11-09   Lrsky - there is nothing wrong with digital (just look at hd ...   Kijanki

02-11-09   Well, we divide there...there is something inherently wrong ...   Lrsky

02-11-09   Lrsky - i don't have enough experience to judge and i use di ...   Kijanki

02-11-09   Your point about digital tape masters leads me back to the o ...   Lrsky

02-11-09   Lrsky - i suspect that better reflection from cd translates ...   Kijanki

02-12-09   The original quote about equality with some being more equal ...   Markphd

02-12-09   Markphd - i just expressed doubts about book (animal farm) b ...   Kijanki

02-12-09   ....kr4 sorry kal, my fingers got ahead of my brain… and t ...   Blindjim

02-12-09   Perhaps a couple of the best sounding albums like "dar ...   Unclejeff

02-12-09   Why not? because, aside from realizing the multichannel asp ...   Kr4

02-12-09   I hope so kal, but the riaa has been really stupid with thei ...   Kennyt

02-12-09   Good for you, it will help. kal   Kr4

02-12-09   Yeah, but will the riaa actually ever produce them so i coul ...   Kennyt

02-12-09   Yes, duh animal farm by orwell, not the book '1984'. damn t ...   Lrsky

02-12-09   I have not read the entire thread, but in response to the ti ...   Tvad

02-12-09   Consenses: aw, the hell with it: just plug alternating hol ...   Unclejeff

02-13-09   Consensus, too strong. has anyone compared blu-ray to a regu ...   Lrsky

02-13-09   Based on sony's history of developing and abandoning formats ...   Tvad

02-13-09   True tvad, but if we're to be realistic, everything digital ...   Lrsky

02-13-09   no it's not. redbook cd has been around for more than two d ...   Tvad

02-13-09   Redbook may have been around, but because of improvements in ...   Lrsky

02-13-09   As i understand the question, you are asking if people belie ...   Tvad

02-14-09   Rightoo tvad. since the soft ware for our primary listening, ...   Lrsky

02-14-09   I own many cds that sound incredibly good. really. they are ...   Tvad

02-14-09   Grant, so do i--and ironically, some are the oldest among th ...   Lrsky


  Post your response
Subject


Your response

No html, but you may use markup tags


Username
Members only

Password