AudiogoN
Search Buy Sell Learn MyPage
 Learn > Forums > Home Theater > 1014610053  Start New Thread | Log In | Bookmark This
  Why is 2 Channel better than multi-channel?
I hear that the music fidelity of a multi-channel AV Receiver/Integrated amp can never match the sounds produced by a 2 channel system. Can someone clearly explain why this is so?

I'm planning to upgrade my HT system to try and achieve the best of both worlds, I currently have a 3 channel amp driving my SL, SR, C and a 2 channel amp driving my L and R.
I have a Denon 3801 acting as my pre. Is there any Pre/Proc out there that can merge both worlds with out breaking my bank? Looking for recommendations on what my next logical steps should be? Thanks in advance.
Springowl  (Threads | Answers | This Thread)

02-24-02
  Responses (1-50 of 247)
Click title to read one, or click date to read all below it.

02-25-02   For the past 50 years or so people have been working to opti ...   Herman

02-25-02   While herman nailed it on the head, you also have to conside ...   Sean

02-25-02   I would agree with sean. when a two channel system is set u ...   Rrlibv

02-25-02   I should add that in many cases mono has better fidelity tha ...   Marakanetz

02-25-02   Technically, it's not. a good multichannel system can provid ...   Bomarc

02-25-02   the quality of imaging available in multichannel systems u ...   Flex

02-25-02   Good thread. glad to see some diverse opinions with valid p ...   Sean

02-25-02   The recording industry is in turmoil just now. i'm sure man ...   Cornfedboy

02-25-02   When i listen to 2 channel audio, what i listen for is reali ...   Hindemith

02-25-02   I agree with most of the above reasons why "2 channel i ...   Gboren

02-25-02   Have you ever noticed that it's often easier to place instru ...   Bomarc

02-25-02   Is anyone out there using the panpot? is it worth to use an ...   Psychicanimal

02-26-02   It's pretty logical and simple: before the digital technolog ...   Marakanetz

02-26-02   Gboren: i think you don't understand the *possibilities* of ...   Bomarc

02-27-02   Bomarc: fair enough. i fully agree about the possibilities ...   Gboren

02-27-02   What about from a signaling perspective? is analog signals t ...   Springowl

03-03-02   Most of us have speakers in the front that cost 4 to 5 times ...   Darrylhifi

03-03-02   Darryl, the speakers in the rear of my ht system are identic ...   Sean

03-03-02   In response to sean's post, who is the 'they', as in 'they'v ...   Flex

03-03-02   My comments were based on what i purchase in terms of record ...   Sean

03-06-02   I have been into ht for a while and currently have a system ...   Asinetar

03-06-02   "certainly not audiophile class." what are you ta ...   Psychicanimal

03-11-02   Most engineers can't get it right with only two channels, i ...   Ubetit

03-13-02   I'm using a primare p30 pre/pro in my 2-channel system. it ...   Stehno

03-13-02   My 2-channel ht is starting to sound *really* good. the swa ...   Psychicanimal

03-29-02   There are some very valid points made in this thread both pr ...   Avideo

03-29-02   Just giving my two cents worth..... it's hard to enjoy your ...   Viggen

03-29-02   My current 2 channel set up does not compromise stereo imagi ...   Psychicanimal

04-03-02   I didn't read all the replys, so i'm not sure if anyone answ ...   Mdomnick

04-23-02   It all depends upon the room and your listening position. i ...   Perkadin

04-24-02   Excellent post, perkadin. you've wrapped up this thread. i ...   Psychicanimal

07-16-02   All of the information that you need for multi-channel stere ...   Redwoodgarden

07-16-02   No, a great deal of information is lost - irretrievably - wh ...   Hearhere

07-16-02   See "stereo or home theatre" under the "misce ...   Unsound

03-06-03   First i wonder how many of the 2 channel supporters have lis ...   Bobstcyr

03-06-03   To tell the truth i love 1ch over 2ch. i always prefere to b ...   Marakanetz

03-06-03   Hey guys- except for one response above, it seems that every ...   Russ_l

06-25-03   @ channel is better than multichannel because multichannel h ...   Audiophanatik

06-25-03   Most of us only have 2 ears.   sstark@

06-25-03   Can't say which sounds better, depends on the recording i gu ...   Sogood51

07-06-03   Springowl, if you're still out there, you must have upgradde ...   Iseekheils

07-22-03   I have developed a hybrid of the two that, in my opinion, is ...   Redwoodgarden

07-28-03   The only reason 2 ch is better then 5.1 is becouse we (you a ...   Izsakmixer

07-28-03   Izsssakmixer...you are absolutely right about having all spe ...   Eldartford

07-30-03: Slappy
There is definatly something to be said about having identical speakers. not just identical drivers, but identical units on all sides.

Sure you can get away with having some towers in the front, some dipole surrounds and a center all from the same manufacturer, but they STILL sound different.

Imaging this, if you have a 2 channel setup, and say you go with a KEF Q1 for the right channel and a KEF Q7 for the left channel. everybody will think you have gone mad.

Well the same applies to HT as well. however, its less noticable in HT because your FL FR do most if not all of the music in movies, and the rears are just for effects. (Primarily)

I refuse to buy a center channel and "Surrounds" for this reason. In fact, that is one of the reasons i sold my whole Deftech speaker set. 2 2004tls, 2 BP66s, and 1 procenter. and my THX certified Av reciever.

After hearing a HT setup with all identical speakers, and all identical channels i realized that going with different speakers even from the same manufacturer degrad3es the sound.

Now im running a DENON 3803, with 192/24b DACs on all 7 channels, 110W on all 7 channels, all identical amplifiers
I bought a set of KEF Q1's (incredible speaker, especially for the price), and now im saving up to buy another, then another. Im going to run all 7 channels of this with 1 type of speaker.

As far as integrated / sepeates is concerned, seperates are probably better, however, i just bought that denon 3803 and its sound quality blows my mind.
I dont think that seperates will always be better, i just think that AV recievers need to do some catching up.
Some day AV recievers will be able to produce as good sound as any pre / amp setup. It just needs more time and R&D

7 Channel stereo mode sounds pretty cool when all your speaks are the same

other than that, i dont believe 2 chan is superior to multichannel. I think multichannel is still a work in progress. I also think it is a matter of personal preference.

I like the versitility of a multichannel setup.

Slappy  (System | Threads | Answers | This Thread)


08-06-03   How about three channel? this is something that i have done ...   Eldartford

08-08-03   I agree with the notion that not having identical speakers d ...   Chucknms

08-09-03   Chucknms...in discrete multichannel recordings (sacd or dvd- ...   Eldartford

08-09-03   True...i should have been more specific and said multi-chann ...   Chucknms

08-09-03   A center channel is not a full range speaker, so, naturally, ...   Viggen


    1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 Next >

  Post your response
Subject


Your response

No html, but you may use markup tags


Username
Members only

Password