AudiogoN
Search Buy Sell Learn MyPage
 Learn > Forums > Home Theater > 1014610053  Start New Thread | Log In | Bookmark This
  Why is 2 Channel better than multi-channel?
I hear that the music fidelity of a multi-channel AV Receiver/Integrated amp can never match the sounds produced by a 2 channel system. Can someone clearly explain why this is so?

I'm planning to upgrade my HT system to try and achieve the best of both worlds, I currently have a 3 channel amp driving my SL, SR, C and a 2 channel amp driving my L and R.
I have a Denon 3801 acting as my pre. Is there any Pre/Proc out there that can merge both worlds with out breaking my bank? Looking for recommendations on what my next logical steps should be? Thanks in advance.
Springowl  (Threads | Answers | This Thread)

02-24-02
  Responses (151-200 of 247)
Click title to read one, or click date to read all below it.

08-07-06   In my experience very few recordings sound completely right ...   Eldartford

08-07-06   Kal said it better than i could. "following that same ...   D_edwards

08-07-06   Hi guys i am not too expierenced with ht.i want to keep it a ...   Alpass

08-08-06   Kal, i'm still a bit confused. when you talk about the reco ...   Snipes

08-08-06   Yes, exactly. running redbook through a processor is highly ...   Kr4

05-20-07   Greetings fellow agoners.while i tried to read as many of th ...   Freediver

05-23-07   Anyone thinking about getting an sacd player..., do it! an s ...   G_clef

07-13-07   I have both. a mcintosh-based 5.1 system in the living room ...   Jaycchristian

01-08-08   In my system, the two channel sacd has better sound quality ...   Asin

08-16-09   Without all the technical knowledge that alot of the posters ...   82audio19

08-18-09   Mostly hi end audio multi or otherwise suffers from environm ...   Undertow

08-22-09   2 channel for me, is better than multi-channel because i hav ...   Talk2me

08-29-09   Many systems can't handle movies that were encoded with mult ...   Unclejeff

09-06-09   I wonder if technology since '02 could have changed the answ ...   Paulsax

10-10-09   Well, you can get a krell hts 5.1 which has a preamp mode wh ...   Tobaccoleafpie

02-02-10   Quadraphonic baby. if that technology ever gets off the gro ...   Ledhed2222

02-02-10   Whoops...i so meant ambisonics, not quadraphonic.   Ledhed2222

02-06-10   Talk about learn something new everyday...i had no idea 2ch ...   Mnnc

02-10-10   no need to wait. today, at ambisonia.com there are over ...   Martin_leese

02-10-10   But where are the decoders martin? other than meridian gear ...   Ledhed2222

02-11-10   02-10-10: ledhed2222 but where are the decoders martin? p ...   Martin_leese

02-28-10   Martin - what you need to realize is that you were 15 years ...   Cdwallace3

05-30-10   I'm not a big fan of multi-channel and it may be because of ...   Hobbyist_and_reader

06-24-10   Well, i've reviewed a lot of responses to this thread, but s ...   Peregrine

07-10-10: Kturner
I have a basic low-budget surround system (head unit, amp, bass and 5 speakers which includes center speaker) in my car that allows me to listen to both 2-channel and surround music--both in discs (DTS CDs, redbook, SACD DVD-A, DVD and redbook) and Dolby ProLogic II processor. The good news on this is that I never miss the sweet spot!

While I agree speaker placement is important, just as important is the disc itself, the quality of the recording and the quality of the mix and mastering engineer. This goes for both 2-channel and multi-channel discs (some with different mixes on the same disc).

I have heard some multichannel discs and/or mixes that surpass 2-channel recordings, though I have 2 channel recordings that do the exact
opposite. Some 2-channel recordings' soundstage sound so lifelike and immersive that you forget you're listening to multichannel! Conversly, I have heard gimmicky 5-channel recordings (SACD and DVD DTS or DD)hat turning off the center channel is the only option. This goes
especially for some recordings where the main vocal is isolated in the center channel...it sounds like there's a ghost in the room. Freaky!

In conclusion, I'm a "plug and play" type guy and hate tweaking. By having either having a 2-channel or 5-channel properly set-up in a stationary position, one really needs all to do is focus on the recording itself. (please exuse any typos.)

Kturner  (Threads | Answers | This Thread)


07-10-10   I've offered a response i think back in 2002 but perhaps i c ...   Stehno

07-10-10   Imo, indeed. you can posit a lot of numbers and create stra ...   Kr4

07-11-10   That's a pretty incredible post, kr4. this is just a sho ...   Stehno

07-11-10   Nope. it was a purely visceral response. kal   Kr4

07-17-10   I have no idea what your budget is, but home theater receive ...   Mceljo

07-29-10   Unlike the vast majority of the responses in this thread, at ...   Russ_l

08-02-10   Thanks for the support, russ. i think. so i guess the point ...   Stehno

08-02-10   The type of reasoning put forth by stehno is flawed and ulti ...   Onhwy61

08-04-10   Actually, onhwy61, whether my response is incorrect or flawe ...   Stehno

08-10-10   2-channel is for purists only!   Jafant

08-10-10   Stupid comment - 2 channel is for anyone who uses it. many p ...   Macrojack

08-10-10   Multichannel is for better music but i understand that other ...   Kr4

08-10-10   The few times i've heard multichannel it never sounded right ...   Sebrof

08-10-10   No. i am acknowledging that decent mch will take up more sp ...   Kr4

08-10-10   Kal - don't forget indifference. most people could care less ...   Macrojack

08-10-10   Surely, macrojack, none of those people are among us!! indi ...   Kr4

08-10-10   "08-10-10: kr4 no. i am acknowledging that decent mch w ...   Sebrof

08-10-10   "at a pricepoint" is not universally understood. ...   Kr4

08-28-10   There is no reason why you can't enjoy both. it does take a ...   Phd

09-05-10   I have been struggling with this myself and have decided aft ...   Larrykantrowitz

10-23-10   I'm a little late to the game here but could not resists wei ...   Edorr

10-24-10   This thread has progressed haltingly through nearly nine yea ...   Macrojack

01-14-11   As a dealer that almost uniquely, currently and continuously ...   Cine100

01-14-11   really? i have rarely ever found a high-end dealer with any ...   Kr4

01-15-11   Kr4, are you saying that you don't beleive that multi chan ...   Cine100


< Prev 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 Next >

  Post your response
Subject


Your response

No html, but you may use markup tags


Username
Members only

Password