AudiogoN
Search Buy Sell Learn MyPage
 Learn > Forums > Amps Preamps > 1264342155  Start New Thread | Log In | Bookmark This
  Tubes vs. solid state.
I just switched back to my ss equipment and can't see how I listened to ss for so many years and thought that I had a good system, maybe the equipment needs to be left on for some time.
But regardless of that, the difference is startling. I know that my tube equipment is not the same degree of excellence as my ss, but now ss sounds lean, thin lifeless. Have my listening priorities changed? One thing I noticed; my listening perception adapts to the sound present in the room. As I write this the sound is improving incremently.
Anyone share the same experience??
I will post as I will continue to listen and notice differences.
Ss is simaudio p-5 w-5, tubes are Cj premier 4 amp and audio experience a2se preamp.
Are there ss preamps that will satisfy or am I smitten by bubes I mean tubes.
Pedrillo  (System | Threads | Answers | This Thread)

01-24-10
  Responses (51-100 of 103)
Click title to read one, or click date to read all below it.

01-26-10   Tvad is right. and your tubed preamp should not be doing th ...   Paulfolbrecht

01-26-10   As someone who tends to prefer ss, i will admit that i like ...   Unsound

01-27-10   To me, a good tube design, sounds a lot more like live music ...   Argyro

01-27-10   Quote pedrilo "...but dislike the bass roll-off and t ...   Argyro

01-27-10   Argyro is completely right. there are tube preamps that go d ...   Atmasphere

01-27-10   The 'best' of both technology are converging with gaps closi ...   Bvdiman

01-27-10   "best attributes of each are pretty much present in eit ...   Phaelon

01-28-10   I have played classical violin for years, listened to live u ...   Minorl

02-01-10   What is the ultimate goal of any design, ss, or tube? is it ...   Olesonmd

02-01-10   Anyone here interested in what chaos theory has to say about ...   Atmasphere

02-01-10   Ralph, yes! and don't spare any of the details.   Unsound

02-01-10   Is it that live music is often reinforced by tube amplified ...   Sciguy47

02-01-10   Instrument amps are often vintage tubed gear...especially gu ...   Tvad

02-01-10   Unamplified acoustic instrument and voice is the standard fo ...   Rtn1

02-01-10   Unamplified comes to mind first whenever live is mentioned.   Pedrillo

02-01-10   where snobbish audiophiles are concerned, that may be true. ...   Tvad

02-01-10: Olesonmd
And the reason tube amps are loved by guitar players is that they overdrive them into distortion frequently. We all know about tubes even order harmonics when overdriven. How many of you overdrive your home stereo to get that classic distorted rock & roll sound that people like Clapton seem to enjoy so much?
I'm not arguing against tubes, but it's my position that they have a much more practical application in the world of guitar amplifiers than in home audio.

Olesonmd  (Answers | This Thread)


02-01-10   Olesonmd has the critical point - the whole point of tubes i ...   Paulfolbrecht

02-01-10   Alright- here are some basics: given an amplifier with a pr ...   Atmasphere

02-01-10   It sounds pretty fascinating. can you reference any papers ...   Paulfolbrecht

02-02-10   A little more fuel on the fire...... "a few music list ...   Olesonmd

02-02-10   Paulfolbrecht, yes, general electric proved that humans use ...   Atmasphere

02-02-10   Anyone who claims that the "overall superior performanc ...   Paulfolbrecht

02-02-10   A-s, of course i pretty much agree with your thoughts. (and ...   Paulfolbrecht

02-02-10   Amazing and very interesting discussion. please keep in min ...   Minorl

02-02-10   Minorl, sounds to me as if you are saying something that i'v ...   Atmasphere

02-02-10   Minorl is touching upon what ralph calls the power-paradigm/ ...   Paulfolbrecht

02-02-10   I'm sorry. who is ralph? i would like to read his papers o ...   Minorl

02-02-10   Minorl, of course there are electric cars too, and energy st ...   Atmasphere

02-02-10   Atmasphere, do zero feedback solid state designs share the s ...   Pinkus

02-03-10   Oh shucks, i must really be tin-eared, because i have never ...   Guidocorona

02-03-10   Guido, i have. and although my sample is limited, i have fo ...   Pinkus

02-03-10   Pinkus, the only issue with transistors is that without feed ...   Atmasphere

02-03-10   Pinkus, our tin ears must be forged from different pewter al ...   Guidocorona

02-04-10   Is hard to decide between them because each person has diffe ...   Chatta

02-04-10   Guidocorona, feedback is very definately a factor in preamp ...   Atmasphere

02-04-10   It is becoming conventional wisdom that the sound of tube an ...   Larryi

02-04-10   Guido, of course feedback can be applied to preamps, and in ...   Pinkus

02-04-10   Likewise pinkus. . . i'd love to have your ears. . . while a ...   Guidocorona

02-05-10   Guido, i have had 2 cj preamps in my system: the venerable ...   Pinkus

02-05-10   I think tube amps sound better on panel speakers, while some ...   Mrtennis

02-08-10   Agree, tubes do magic if done right. so can ss amps. but, st ...   Nilthepill

02-10-10   Now that i have sold my asr emitter, i can comment on it a b ...   Paulfolbrecht

02-10-10   well said, guido!!! and so refreshingly different from one ...   Swampwalker

02-14-10   Although i have owned ss most of my life, after switching to ...   Orpheus10

02-14-10   Orpheus10, i feel the same way! until summer hits, when i ha ...   Pedrillo

02-14-10   Never say never. i have auditioned some very nice equipment ...   Minorl

02-14-10   Great conversation guys ! i have heard great music out o ...   Weseixas

02-15-10   provocative position, ralph. given the "perceptual rul ...   C1ferrari

02-15-10   I was under the same inpression, but after selling my juicyp ...   52tiger

02-15-10   Hi sam, ime the most transparent systems i have heard are al ...   Atmasphere

02-15-10   Ralph i was wondering your opinion on tube dampers and if yo ...   Rleff

02-15-10   Tube dampers work but they have limited effect. you are best ...   Atmasphere


< Prev 1 | 2

  Post your response
Subject


Your response

No html, but you may use markup tags


Username
Members only

Password