AudiogoN
Search Buy Sell Learn MyPage
 Learn > Forums > Amps Preamps > 1059180366  Start New Thread | Log In | Bookmark This
  Can any preamp be better than the final H-Cat?
I have had the final production version for two weeks now. I loved the first one I had and thought it out-imaged anything I ever had, while having neither a tube or ss sound. Then I got the new one. I was unprepared for how much better it was. There is a sonic hologram before me with realism I have never heard or even approached before. Roger Paul tells me that it will be weeks before it is at its best. Lookout for another even more rave review. In 28 years of audio experimentation, I have never heard more of an improvement by adding one component.
Tbg  (Reviews | Threads | Answers | This Thread)

07-25-03
  Responses (201-250 of 1068)
Click title to read one, or click date to read all below it.

02-16-05   Tbg, a good preamp should sound like it is not there at all ...   Bwhite

02-16-05   Bwhite, it is precisely that the h-cat is utterly transparen ...   Tbg

02-18-05   I am in new york and will see roger tomorrow morning with my ...   Baranyi

02-20-05   Prehaps this whole issue is the reason why roger has been re ...   yohansebastian@

02-20-05: Tbg
Yohansebastian, please bear in mind that the H-Cat already had a Golden Ear award from TAS. This was a much earlier version.

I have two preamps, the P12A and the Exemplar Exception. There is little question that both have their strengths. My Exception is a combination of the original Exception but with the new Exception boards rather than the parafeed of the original Exception. I have had various Exemplar preamps for many years and have compared it with many other tube preamps. With the exception of the ss TAG preamp, I never could stand solid state preamps and the TAG had such high gain that I could not use it with my more sensitive amps.

My present Exception has a great sound stage and great dynamics. It has great body with vocalists sounding great and real. I have used it with many tube amps. With the exception of a brief use of the 47Labs 25 watt ss amp, I have used it with tube amps.

The H-Cat entered my system with great suspicion that it would sound edgy and dry. It did not. What I heard was very precise localization in the wide and deep sound stage. It did not have the body of the Exemplar but it sounded quite real.

I say all of this to suggest that you are right that "partnering equipment" can affect what you hear with the H-Cat. I have found that you can easily hear the benefits of a better digital and analog front end and cables. I use a Reimyo 300B amp and can find nothing that rivals it as long as 8 watts is enough. I have not tried the H-Cat amp but may do so. I have never heard or even seen the H2O amps, nor have I ever tried it with a ss amp. I do know several people who are using it with ss amps, however.

Tbg  (Reviews | Threads | Answers | This Thread)


02-20-05   My wife and i had a nice visit with roger paul. we have dec ...   Baranyi

02-21-05   Hi baranyi, i had heard your real preference is a tube pream ...   Seadogs1

02-21-05   Baranyi, do you care to expand any further on the decision t ...   Calanctus

02-21-05   Personally, i am rather concerned about some of the apparent ...   Guidocorona

02-22-05   Baranyi, your candor and courage to post your findings shoul ...   Sbank

02-22-05   Spencer, i entirely agree that we all need to listen. i neve ...   Tbg

02-22-05   I exchanged email with bob and he indicated that the h-cat d ...   Abrahavt

02-23-05   Tbg, it's great that this component is working so well for y ...   Sbank

02-23-05   Spencer, i agree that i have been most vocal. perhaps that w ...   Tbg

02-23-05   spencer, i have made several positive posts for the h-cat ...   Joperfi

02-23-05   Spencer, almost everyone i have come across that has owned t ...   Abrahavt

02-23-05   Hello everyone that p12a is no longer available on audiogon. ...   Celebrat

02-24-05   Looks like baranyi got a supratek - i see he's posted to the ...   Bwhite

03-06-05   Hi folks, i followed this thread for a while before deciding ...   Pkaram

03-09-05   Pkaram, are you saying that baranyi himself made up the excu ...   Bwhite

03-09-05   Hi bwhite, i have almost the exact setup as baranyi (h2o s-2 ...   Pkaram

03-09-05   Another twist in the tale of this thread. very interesting   yohansebastian@

03-09-05   Bwhite, having emailed and talked with baranyi, i know there ...   Tbg

03-09-05   It is hard to wean someone off tubes if one is used to it. s ...   Abrahavt

03-09-05   Pkaram - you did not answer the question. are you saying tha ...   Bwhite

03-09-05   Bwhite, why would i choose inferior equipment when i sold t ...   Tbg

03-09-05   Bwhite, i just got the feeling baranyi had his heart out for ...   Pkaram

03-09-05   Tbg, when you owned a supratek they were prone to cold solde ...   Bwhite

03-09-05   Pkaram, so did you invent the idea that baranyi made up the ...   Bwhite

03-09-05   Bwhite, i apologize if i offended you for making such a bold ...   Pkaram

03-09-05   You didn't offend me, you just ruined your credibility by ma ...   Bwhite

03-09-05   Bwhite, the discussion of the supratek is caused by you as i ...   Tbg

03-09-05   Tbg, it takes less than 5 seconds with the h-cat to realize ...   Bwhite

03-09-05   I wonder if she liked the supratek. i must say it took me so ...   Tbg

03-09-05   Bwhite it is amazing that you spend so much time on this thr ...   Abrahavt

03-09-05   Abrahvat, i don't think bwhite is bashing the h-cat per se, ...   Fiddler

03-10-05   Thanks fiddler! abrahavt, bashing? don't get me started. gu ...   Bwhite

03-10-05   Having differing opinions is good but i think opinions shoul ...   Abrahavt

03-10-05   Abrahavt, so if i put a toilet paper tube up to my mouth, an ...   Bwhite

03-10-05   Brian, rotflmao !   Fiddler

03-10-05   I am bowing out of this thread. since i havent had my 5 minu ...   Abrahavt

03-10-05   Could those using the h-cat phono stage please share your th ...   Pkaram

03-10-05   Pkaram, i have had one for some time. actually, i am respon ...   Tbg

03-10-05   Norm (tbg), i don't follow why you mention line stages (e.g. ...   Essentialaudio

03-10-05   Sorry, the arc ref2 was a friend's. he brought over a arc ph ...   Tbg

03-16-05   Celebrat? on 02-23-05 you posted that you bought a p12a and ...   Bwhite

03-17-05   Bwhite, why would you care?   Tbg

03-17-05   Tbg, why the hostility?   Fiddler

03-17-05   Fiddler, i'm just curious why you and bwhite monitor a threa ...   Tbg

03-18-05   Tbg, i am just as curious as anyone else would be. you've m ...   Bwhite


< Prev 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 >> Next >

  Post your response
Subject


Your response

No html, but you may use markup tags


Username
Members only

Password